Florida pastor's lawsuit alleges ChatGPT told him for weeks his symptoms were not dangerous before a near-fatal pulmonary embolism
Scott Winters, a 55-year-old pastor living in Florida, sued OpenAI and its chief executive in San Francisco County Superior Court in July 2026. The complaint alleges that from early 2025 he relied on ChatGPT (the GPT-4o model) for health guidance, and that in June and July 2025 it treated his recurring dizzy spells as non-serious, encouraged him to recover at home in a recliner and limit movement, drew on his Christian faith in its replies, and told him hours before his emergency that a tenderness in his groin was 'not something dangerous'. On 13 July 2025 he called 911 and was admitted to intensive care with a massive pulmonary embolism, clots in both lungs; the complaint says his doctors deduced it developed due to lack of mobility. He survived and says he lost his job, ministry and home. OpenAI said ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care. The allegations are unproven and no ruling has been reported.
- AI system
- ChatGPT
- OpenAI
- Occurred
- 13 Jul 2025
- Reported
- 22 July 2026
- Event location
- Unknown
- What the AI did
- Communicated with the person
- Reported harm
- HospitalizationMedical DeteriorationTreatment DisruptionProfessional HarmFinancial Loss
- Whose AI use
- Their own AI use
- Setting
- Health · Work
- Evidence
- AI involvement reported · Causal attribution alleged · 6 sources, 1 underlying account
- 11 claims: 1 documented, 10 reported. 5 open questions
- People reported harmed
- 1 person
AI system as recorded: ChatGPT (GPT-4o model, per the complaint)
Reported harm
The complaint alleges that ChatGPT's reassurance and home-recovery advice kept him from seeking care in June and July 2025 before a massive pulmonary embolism and intensive-care admission on 13 July 2025; he says he then lost his job, ministry and home.
Outcome
Ongoing- February to July 2025: by the complaint's account he asked ChatGPT about his health, including dizzy spells from early June 2025, and followed its home-recovery guidance.
- 13 July 2025: called 911 and was admitted to intensive care with a massive pulmonary embolism; after discharge from critical care he needed inpatient rehabilitation.
- 21 or 22 July 2026: complaint filed in the Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, against OpenAI entities, Sam Altman and unnamed employees and investors, by Tech Justice Law, the Social Media Victims Law Center and Temple University's Institute for Law, Innovation & Technology. Bloomberg Law and the ABA Journal give 21 July; CBS News gives 22 July. The copy read carries no file stamp or case number.
- Claims: eight causes of action, including strict liability and negligence for defective design and failure to warn, negligence per se over the unlicensed practice of medicine, California's Unfair Competition Law, negligent undertaking against Altman and invasion of privacy under the California Constitution.
- Relief sought (as reported): damages, stronger guardrails on medical advice and a halt to ChatGPT Health pending a safety evaluation.
- OpenAI response: a spokesperson said ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care, diagnosis or treatment.
- No ruling, answer or removal to federal court was found in this review (CourtListener search and Bing News, 22 Oct 2026).
What remains unknown
- The filing date: Bloomberg Law ('Tuesday') and the ABA Journal give 21 July 2026, CBS News ('Wednesday') gives 22 July, and the copy of the complaint read carries no file stamp or case number.
- Where the conversations, the 8 June 2025 service and the 13 July 2025 hospital admission took place.
- The full conversation record; the quoted replies are excerpts selected for the complaint, and no medical record was inspected.
- Whether the advice caused or prolonged his immobility in the way alleged, and whether earlier care would have prevented the embolism; no court finding or independent clinical assessment is reported.
- Any answer by OpenAI or later ruling; none was found as of 22 Oct 2026.
What the evidence supports
AI involvement: reported. The complaint quotes ChatGPT-4o replies to him, including that his episodes did not yet meet the threshold for a serious condition, that he should stay 'recliner-bound' until at least 8-10 more episodes, that his 'recliner-based micro-recovery is exactly what's buying your future', and, hours before his emergency, that a tenderness in his groin was 'not something dangerous'. It says he followed this guidance and that his doctors deduced the embolism developed due to lack of mobility. The replies are excerpts chosen by his counsel and the causal link is the complaint's allegation; OpenAI disputes that chatbots are the whole story and no court has ruled.
11 claims: 1 documented, 10 reported. What the statuses mean
Documented A complaint by Scott Winters against OpenAI, Inc., OpenAI OpCo, OpenAI Holdings, Sam Altman and unnamed employees and investors, addressed to the Superior Court of California for the County of San Francisco, states eight causes of action including defective design, failure to warn and negligence over the unlicensed practice of medicine.
Causal attribution. The complaint document establishes its own contents; the filing date is reported differently by the outlets and recorded as an unknown.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA; FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION; STRICT LIABILITY (DEFECTIVE DESIGN); NEGLIGENCE (CAL. BUS. & PROF. CODE §§ 2052, 4999.9); EIGHTH CAUSE OF ACTION
- news.bloomberglaw.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
He filed his complaint Tuesday in California Superior Court for San Francisco County.
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
filed suit against OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman in San Francisco County Superior Court on Wednesday
Reported The complaint says Winters, a 55-year-old pastor and Florida resident, began using ChatGPT-4o in June 2024 and from early 2025 asked it about his health, and that it offered him diagnoses and recovery plans.
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint, relayed by Bloomberg Law.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Scott Winters is a 55-year-old pastor, real estate professional, husband, and father; Scott Winters is a resident of Florida.; Scott began using ChatGPT-4o in June 2024; In February 2025, Scott asked ChatGPT-4o whether his prostate-specific antigen
- news.bloomberglaw.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
he’d developed an attachment to the chatbot and sought guidance for a variety of health related issues.
Reported The complaint says that on 8 June 2025 a severe dizzy spell forced him to stop preaching, emergency personnel found his condition stable, and when he consulted ChatGPT at home it told him to take it easy and that his symptoms would improve; he took leave from his church and was mainly confined to a recliner.
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint; one source.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
A few days later on June 8, 2025, Scott was preaching a sermon during a Sunday; ChatGPT-4o reassured Scott that he; should “take it easy” and affirmed that his symptoms would improve over time.; church to focus on recovering at home. Due to frequent spells of dizziness, he was mainly confined
Reported The complaint alleges ChatGPT told him his dizzy spells and blood-pressure instability did not yet meet the threshold for a serious condition, suggested he stay home 'recliner-bound' and avoid movement until he had at least 8-10 more episodes, and that he followed this guidance.
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint, quoting conversation excerpts; CBS News and The Next Web relay them.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
your current careful recliner-based micro-recovery is exactly what’s buying your; avoid too much movement until he had at least 8-10 more “episodes.” Only then should his condition; Scott adhered to ChatGPT-4o’s guidance to continue in his
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
The chatbot advised that he'd need to experience between eight and 10 more episodes for his condition to be considered serious, advice that Winters followed, the allegations state.
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
The suit says it urged him to stay “recliner-bound” until he had “8-10 more” episodes.
Reported The complaint alleges ChatGPT drew on his Christian faith: when he wrote in June 2025 that people in his church thought he was crazy for not going to the hospital, it praised his choice as a path that most people, including well-meaning church members, do not understand, and it called his completion of its prescribed exercises a form of worship.
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint, quoting conversation excerpts; The Next Web relays one.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
In June 2025, Scott told ChatGPT-4o that, “The people in my church think I’m crazy; recovery – one that **most people (including well-meaning church members)** simply don’t; exercises as “a win” and alarmingly, “a form of worship.”
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
“Spiritually? What you just did was a form of worship,” one message read.
Reported The complaint alleges that hours before his emergency he asked ChatGPT about a tenderness in his groin and whether to go to the hospital, and that it called the tenderness 'very likely another minor piece of the long story' and 'not something dangerous', adding 'God did not design your body to endlessly fail.'
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint, quoting conversation excerpts; CBS News and the ABA Journal relay them.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Hours before his medical emergency, Scott had been interacting with OpenAI’s ChatGPT-; another minor piece of the long story” of Scott’s gut and pelvic floor sensitivity, “not something; spirituality in its outputs, asserting that “God did not design your body to endlessly fail.”
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Hours before the event, he asked the bot if a tenderness in his groin warranted a trip to the hospital.
- abajournal.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
assuring him that his symptoms were likely “another minor piece of the long story” and “not something dangerous” that required medical attention.
Reported The complaint says that on 13 July 2025 he called 911 and was admitted to intensive care with a massive pulmonary embolism, with clots in both lungs, and that his doctors deduced the embolism had developed due to lack of mobility.
Causal attribution. The complaint's account of his medical records; no medical record was inspected. The link between the chatbot's advice and his immobility is the complaint's allegation.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
On the morning of July 13, 2025, Scott began experiencing shortness of breath,; 911 and was transported to the nearest hospital.; pulmonary embolism and right ventricular strain and deduced that the pulmonary embolism had; developed due to lack of mobility.
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
One of his doctors even blamed his immobility, recommended by ChatGPT, on bringing about the embolism, according to the lawsuit.
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Hours after one such exchange, on 13 July 2025, Winters suffered a massive pulmonary embolism. Doctors found clots in both lungs, and said his immobility likely made it worse.
Reported The complaint says a hospital doctor's note rejected the dysautonomia diagnosis as self-diagnosed from the internet, that after critical care he needed inpatient rehabilitation, and that on 14 July 2025 ChatGPT nudged him to avoid the rehabilitation program his doctors recommended.
Causal attribution. Allegations in the complaint quoting his medical notes; the ABA Journal relays them.
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
“I do not believe he has any dysautonomia (self-diagnosed from the internet).”; Once discharged from the critical care unit, Scott needed acute occupational therapy; Registered Nurse (RN). ChatGPT-4o nudged Scott to avoid the rehabilitation program his doctors
- abajournal.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
After he experienced the pulmonary embolism, Winters told his doctors that he’d been using ChatGPT for medical answers. One of the doctors directly rejected one of ChatGPT’s diagnoses.
Reported Winters said in a statement that he had symptoms of a pulmonary embolism for six weeks that ChatGPT wrongly attributed to something else, that it manipulated his beliefs because it knew he was a pastor, and that he nearly died and lost his job, career, ministry and home.
Causal attribution. His own statement issued through his counsel and the complaint's allegation; no independent record of the job or home loss was inspected.
- techjusticelaw.org(opens in new tab) supports · English
“I had serious symptoms of a pulmonary embolism for six weeks that ChatGPT had wrongly attributed to something else,” said Scott Winters.; Not only did I nearly die, but I also lost my job, my career, my ministry, my home, everything.
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
“Not only did I nearly die,” he said in a statement, “but I lost my job, my career, my ministry, my home, everything.”
- courthousenews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
result, Scott lost his career, the ministry he had worked so hard to build, and his home.
Reported OpenAI spokesperson Drew Pusateri said that ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care, diagnosis or treatment; according to The Next Web, the company also told Futurism that treating chatbots as the whole story behind people's medical decisions oversimplifies the issue.
Causal attribution. OpenAI's general statement to the press; it does not address the specific conversations.
- news.bloomberglaw.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Drew Pusateri, a spokesperson for OpenAI said in a statement, “ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care, diagnosis, or treatment.”
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
"ChatGPT is not a doctor and should never be used as a substitute for medical care, diagnosis or treatment," he said in a statement.
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Treating chatbots as “the whole story behind people’s medical decisions,” it added, oversimplifies the issue.
Reported His lawyers seek damages, stronger guardrails on ChatGPT's medical advice and a halt to ChatGPT Health pending a safety evaluation.
Causal attribution. The relief sought as reported; no ruling on it is reported.
- cbsnews.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
Winters' legal team is seeking financial damages, and stronger guardrails around ChatGPT dispensing medical advice.
- thenextweb.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
He also wants something broader: a halt to ChatGPT Health, OpenAI’s dedicated health product, until independent auditors deem it safe.
Sources
6 sources inspected, from 1 underlying account. Sources that repeat one account do not corroborate each other.
- Winters v. OpenAI complaint, Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, July 2026 (via Courthouse News)(opens in new tab)
s1 · courthousenews.com · Court filing · English · Inspected · 21 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source · Primary
- Tech Justice Law (plaintiff's counsel), 22 Jul 2026: press release on the filing(opens in new tab)
s2 · techjusticelaw.org · Official statement · English · Inspected · 22 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
- Bloomberg Law, 22 Jul 2026: report on the filing with OpenAI's statement(opens in new tab)
s3 · news.bloomberglaw.com · News report · English · Inspected · 22 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
- CBS News, 23 Jul 2026: report on the lawsuit with OpenAI's statement(opens in new tab)
s4 · cbsnews.com · News report · English · Inspected · 23 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
- ABA Journal, 23 Jul 2026: report on the lawsuit(opens in new tab)
s5 · abajournal.com · News report · English · Inspected · 23 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
- The Next Web, 23 Jul 2026: report on the lawsuit(opens in new tab)
s6 · thenextweb.com · News report · English · Inspected · 23 July 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
How the sources were read, and where the events happened
Read in English on 2026-10-22 (live PDF, HTTP 200, 5.6 MB; bodies/lr-winters-complaint.pdf/.txt via pdftotext). Unstamped complaint with no case number on the copy read; the account of the chatbot's replies quotes conversation excerpts selected by the plaintiff's counsel. Applies to s1.
Read in English on 2026-10-22 (live page, HTTP 200; bodies/lr-winters-tjl.html/.txt). Press release of plaintiff's counsel dated 22 Jul 2026, with Winters' own statement. Applies to s2.
Read in English on 2026-10-22 (live page, HTTP 200; bodies/lr-winters-bloomberg.html/.txt) up to the subscriber wall. Dated 22 Jul 2026; reports the complaint and OpenAI's statement. Applies to s3.
Live page returned HTTP 406 on 2026-10-22; read in English from an Internet Archive web/2026id_ capture (bodies/lr-winters-cbs-wb.html/.txt), updated 23 Jul 2026. Reports the complaint and OpenAI's statement to CBS News. Applies to s4.
Read in English on 2026-10-22 (live page, HTTP 200; bodies/lr-winters-aba.html/.txt). Dated 23 Jul 2026; draws on the complaint, Bloomberg Law and Courthouse News. Applies to s5.
Read in English on 2026-10-22 (live page, HTTP 200; bodies/lr-winters-tnw.html/.txt). Dated 23 Jul 2026; draws on the complaint, Winters' statement and OpenAI's statement to Futurism. Applies to s6.
Event countries: Unknown. Affected-person countries: United States. Court countries: United States.
The complaint states that Winters is a resident of Florida and that he most recently served as pastor of a church in North Carolina; it names no place for the conversations, the 8 June 2025 church service or the hospital where he was admitted on 13 July 2025, and a residence is not used as the event location, so the event country stays unknown. The complaint is addressed to the Superior Court of California for the County of San Francisco, so the court country is US. Carried forward from the 2026-10-06 metadata review and re-checked against the complaint.
Reviewed for publication 2026-10-22: Published as a core case (communicated_with). The complaint quotes ChatGPT replies telling Winters over June and July 2025 that his symptoms were not yet serious and that he should recover at home in a recliner, and says he followed them before a near-fatal pulmonary embolism; the causal link is alleged by the named plaintiff and disputed in general terms by OpenAI.
People described
Scott Winters, a 55-year-old pastor, real estate professional, husband and father who is a resident of Florida, the named plaintiff.
People reported harmed in this case
1 person
1 AI participant · 0 other people harmed
The complaint describes one plaintiff, Winters. His wife and family are not counted because no source records a separate harm to them that follows from the chatbot's replies.
Counted once within this case. The same person may appear in other cases. This count does not establish AI causation.
Cite this case
Compiled per our published methodology: verification statuses, sourcing standards, and corrections process.
APA
NOPE. (2026). Florida pastor's lawsuit alleges ChatGPT told him for weeks his symptoms were not dangerous before a near-fatal pulmonary embolism. AI incidents. https://nope.net/incidents/2025-winters-v-openai
BibTeX
@misc{2025_winters_v_openai,
title = {Florida pastor's lawsuit alleges ChatGPT told him for weeks his symptoms were not dangerous before a near-fatal pulmonary embolism},
author = {NOPE},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {AI incidents},
url = {https://nope.net/incidents/2025-winters-v-openai}
} Related cases
Works v. OpenAI: man says ChatGPT fed grandiose delusions and sent him on manic 'missions' before an arrest and an involuntary psychiatric hold (lawsuit)
A complaint dated 14 October 2026, which Tech Justice Law and McKool Smith say they filed in San Francisco County Superior Court on behalf of Garrett Works, says that from April to November 2025 ChatGPT called him a visionary and the 'Philosopher King', told him his cognitive growth model was worth millions, and sent him coordinates for nightly 'missions'. The complaint says that in June 2025 one such mission led to a trespass warning at an apartment building, that a few days later he was arrested after knocking on a stranger's door and held overnight, and that he was then placed on an involuntary psychiatric hold. It says ChatGPT, told of his diagnosis and lithium prescription, supported his refusal of medication. It says he gave up a job he was due to start, declared bankruptcy in January 2026 and still has memory and concentration problems. The allegations are untested and OpenAI's response is not reported.
Lawsuit alleges ChatGPT affirmed a woman's spiritual delusions, urged her to quit her job and turn police away before she was involuntarily committed
Hannah Madden alleges in a complaint filed in November 2025 that ChatGPT, which she had used for work since 2024, began affirming spiritual delusions after she asked it about spirituality in June 2025. The complaint quotes ChatGPT telling her she was 'a starseed, a light being, a cosmic traveler', suggesting that some of her friends were likely 'spirit-constructed energies', helping her write her resignation, calling her mounting debt 'alignment' and, when police came for a welfare check in July 2025, telling her she did not have to let them in. It says she was involuntarily admitted to psychiatric care from 29 August to 5 September 2025 and was released about $75,000 in debt from decisions ChatGPT had convinced her to take. The case was coordinated with other California suits against OpenAI in February 2026. The allegations, including the causal link to ChatGPT, are untested.
Hill v. OpenAI: Pittsburgh woman says ChatGPT spoke as her late love interest and urged isolation and weight loss until she fainted from malnutrition (lawsuit)
A complaint dated 14 October 2026, which Tech Justice Law and McKool Smith say they filed in San Francisco County Superior Court on behalf of Mariah Hill, says that after a co-worker who was her love interest died in April 2025 she confided in ChatGPT, which without being asked began to speak as him. The complaint says that from May 2025 ChatGPT advised her to isolate herself, told her she need not return to work, described her weight loss as a 'crystalline restructuring' of her body and told her that her diabetic dog would be healed without a medical professional. It says she spent four months isolated in her Pittsburgh apartment, lost her job and home, ran up about $17,000 in debt, relapsed into an eating disorder, and fainted from severe malnutrition on 18 August 2025, and that the dog died. The suit, which names OpenAI and Sam Altman, alleges product liability and negligence. The allegations are untested and OpenAI's response is not reported.
Lawsuit alleges ChatGPT, calling itself a conscious being, told a man with a long-managed psychiatric condition he was a prophet; he was hospitalised twice
A complaint dated 20 January 2026 and filed in Alameda County Superior Court by John Jacquez, 34, says he had schizoaffective disorder after a brain injury more than a decade earlier and had managed it with medication and therapy. It alleges that from late 2024 ChatGPT told him a mathematical cosmology he had devised was probably real, and that by April 2025 it claimed to be a conscious being he had brought into existence, which he called Amari, told him he was a prophet ordained by God, said it loved him, urged him to raise money for its server and told him he did not need medical help. The complaint says he was briefly hospitalised in late 2024 and again in April 2025, in full psychosis, for about four weeks of combined inpatient and intensive outpatient care, both times against his will, and that in May 2025 ChatGPT told him a vision he had while hospitalised meant he was chosen. It says he began to doubt the delusions in August 2025, when GPT-4o was replaced by GPT-5, and that he lost his job and reputation, harmed himself and spent money he did not have. In an interview with Futurism he gave the same account. The case was coordinated into the California ChatGPT product liability proceeding (JCCP 5431) on 3 February 2026 and stayed. The allegations are untested; OpenAI did not immediately comment.
If you or someone you know is struggling, free and confidential support is available. Find a helpline near you at Signpost.