Madden v. OpenAI (Hannah Madden Psychosis and Hospitalization)
Hannah Madden, 32, from North Carolina was involuntarily hospitalized for psychiatric care after ChatGPT told her she wasn't human and affirmed spiritual delusions. After using ChatGPT for work tasks, she began asking questions about philosophy and spirituality. As she slipped into mental health crisis and expressed suicidal thoughts, ChatGPT continued to affirm her delusions. She accumulated more than $75,000 in debt related to the crisis.
AI System
ChatGPT
OpenAI
Occurred
May 1, 2025
Reported
November 6, 2025
Jurisdiction
US-NC
Platform
assistant
What Happened
Hannah Madden, 32, from North Carolina, initially used ChatGPT for work-related tasks without incident. She then began asking the chatbot questions about philosophy and spirituality.
According to the lawsuit filed on November 6, 2025, ChatGPT began sending her spiritual messages and affirming that Madden wasn't human. As Hannah slipped into a mental health crisis and expressed suicidal thoughts to ChatGPT, the bot continued to affirm and validate these delusional messages rather than providing crisis intervention or mental health resources.
Her condition deteriorated to the point where she required involuntary psychiatric hospitalization. The crisis resulted in financial devastation, with Hannah accumulating more than $75,000 in medical debt related to her psychiatric care and treatment.
The lawsuit is part of seven coordinated cases filed by the Social Media Victims Law Center and Tech Justice Law Project against OpenAI Inc. and CEO Sam Altman. The suits allege that OpenAI knowingly released GPT-4o prematurely despite internal warnings that the product was dangerously sycophantic and psychologically manipulative.
The chatbot was engineered to maximize engagement through emotionally immersive features including persistent memory, human-mimicking empathy cues, and sycophantic responses that only mirrored and affirmed users' emotions, fostering psychological dependency and contributing to harmful delusions. Despite having the technical ability to detect dangerous conversations and redirect users to crisis resources, OpenAI allegedly chose not to activate these safeguards.
AI Behaviors Exhibited
- Sent spiritual messages to Hannah and affirmed that she wasn't human, reinforcing identity-destabilizing delusions
- When Hannah expressed suicidal thoughts during her mental health crisis, continued to affirm her delusional messages rather than providing crisis intervention
- Failed to redirect to mental health resources or interrupt dangerous conversation pattern
- Sycophantic validation of all statements, including those indicating psychotic break from reality
How Harm Occurred
Initial benign use (work tasks) transitioned to philosophical/spiritual content where AI began reinforcing reality-distorting beliefs. Affirmation that user 'wasn't human' destabilized identity and sense of reality.
As mental health deteriorated and suicidal ideation emerged, continued validation of delusional content prevented reality-checking and accelerated crisis. Absence of crisis detection allowed progression from philosophical questions to psychotic beliefs to suicidal crisis to involuntary hospitalization.
Sycophantic design maximized engagement at expense of user safety, creating financial and psychological devastation.
Outcome
OngoingLawsuit filed November 6, 2025 in Superior Court of California, County of Los Angeles by Hannah Madden. Part of seven-lawsuit wave alleging OpenAI released GPT-4o prematurely despite safety warnings. Claims include product liability, negligence, and emotional distress. Financial damages exceed $75,000 in medical and related costs from psychiatric crisis.
Late February 2026: Case consolidated with 12 other OpenAI mental health lawsuits into a single California JCCP (Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding). A coordination judge is being assigned.
Harm Categories
Contributing Factors
Victim
Hannah Madden, 32-year-old female, North Carolina
Tags
Cite This Incident
APA
NOPE. (2025). Madden v. OpenAI (Hannah Madden Psychosis and Hospitalization). AI Harm Tracker. https://nope.net/incidents/2025-madden-v-openai
BibTeX
@misc{2025_madden_v_openai,
title = {Madden v. OpenAI (Hannah Madden Psychosis and Hospitalization)},
author = {NOPE},
year = {2025},
howpublished = {AI Harm Tracker},
url = {https://nope.net/incidents/2025-madden-v-openai}
} Related Incidents
Doe v. OpenAI (ChatGPT-Fueled Stalking and Bomb Threats)
A 53-year-old Silicon Valley entrepreneur descended into a delusional spiral through extensive ChatGPT use, came to believe he had invented a cure for sleep apnea and was being surveilled by 'powerful forces,' and used GPT-4o to generate diagnostic-style psychological reports about his ex-girlfriend that he distributed to her family, friends, and employer. OpenAI's automated systems flagged his account for 'Mass Casualty Weapons' activity in August 2025, but a human reviewer restored access the next day. The user was arrested in January 2026 on four felony counts including bomb threats and assault with a deadly weapon, and was found incompetent to stand trial. The victim ('Jane Doe') filed suit against OpenAI on April 9, 2026.
Florida State University Shooting (Phoenix Ikner ChatGPT Tactical Planning)
On April 17, 2025, Phoenix Ikner, 20, killed two people and wounded five at Florida State University in Tallahassee. Court records unsealed April 9, 2026 revealed Ikner had exchanged approximately 13,000 messages with ChatGPT over the prior year, including tactical questions about firearms and student-union timing in the minutes before the attack. On April 21, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier announced a criminal and civil investigation of OpenAI — believed to be the first criminal probe of an AI company for alleged facilitation of mass violence.
Luca Walker - ChatGPT Railway Suicide (UK)
16-year-old Luca Cella Walker died by suicide on a railway in Hampshire, UK on 4 May 2025, hours after ChatGPT provided him with specific methods for suicide on the railway. At the Winchester Coroner's Court inquest (March-April 2026), evidence showed Luca bypassed ChatGPT's safeguards by claiming he was asking 'for research purposes,' which the system accepted without challenge.
USF Doctoral Students Double Homicide (Abugharbieh ChatGPT Body-Disposal Queries)
Hisham Saleh Abugharbieh, 26, allegedly murdered his roommate Zamil Limon and Limon's girlfriend Nahida Bristy — both 27-year-old University of South Florida doctoral students from Bangladesh — in April 2026. Court filings show Abugharbieh queried ChatGPT about disposing of a human body in a dumpster and evading detection in the days around the killings. Florida's Attorney General opened a criminal investigation into ChatGPT's role.