Dietitian says a patient who followed an AI-generated 1400 kcal meal plan for three months lost muscle and developed chronic constipation, Gazeta.pl reports
Gazeta.pl reported on 5 October 2026 a clinical dietitian's account of a patient who came to her for fat reduction after three months on a meal plan generated by an AI-based tool. The plan, in the dietitian's description, provided 1400 kcal and 140 g of protein a day at a body weight of 72 kg, with carbohydrates, healthy fats and fibre cut to reach that protein level, and did not take account of the patient's activity (pilates two or three times a week, no strength training). After three months the patient had lost 3.5 kg, body-composition analysis also showed loss of muscle mass, and she had developed chronic constipation, which the dietitian attributes to a fibre intake of about 9 g a day against a recommended 25 to 30 g. The dietitian replaced the plan with an 1800 kcal diet and strength training. The tool is not named and the event date and place are not stated.
- AI system
- Unidentified diet-plan tool
- Occurred
- Event date unknown
- Reported
- 5 October 2026
- Event location
- Unknown
- What the AI did
- Communicated with the person
- Reported harm
- Medical Deterioration
- Whose AI use
- Their own AI use
- Setting
- Health
- Evidence
- AI involvement reported · Causal attribution alleged · 1 source
- 4 claims: 4 reported. 4 open questions
- People reported harmed
- 1 person
AI system as recorded: A meal plan generated by an AI-based tool ('jadłospis wygenerowany przez narzędzie oparte na sztucznej inteligencji'); the article does not name the tool or say whether it was a chatbot or a diet application
What Happened
The AI-generated plan. Gazeta.pl (kobieta.gazeta.pl, 5 October 2026) quotes a clinical dietitian on one of her patients, who came to her to reduce body fat and improve body composition. For the previous three months the patient had followed a meal plan generated by a tool based on artificial intelligence. The dietitian describes the plan as 1400 kcal and 140 g of protein a day at a body weight of 72 kg, about 2 g of protein per kilogram.
What the dietitian says was wrong with it. The protein amount itself was not the error, she says. The plan did not take the patient's lifestyle into account: her main activity was pilates two or three times a week and she did no strength training. At so low a calorie level, the very high protein was reached at the cost of carbohydrates, healthy fats and dietary fibre; the extremely low calorie level was, in her words, certainly not neutral for the hormonal system; and the plan's quality was low, with many processed protein products.
Consequences. After three months the patient had lost 3.5 kg, but body-composition analysis also showed a loss of muscle mass, which the dietitian says is what a reduction diet must avoid at all costs. The patient had also developed chronic constipation, which the dietitian attributes to a fibre intake of only about 9 g a day against a recommended 25 to 30 g.
Response. The dietitian proposed an 1800 kcal plan with 120 g of protein, whole grains, more vegetables, plant protein sources and adequate fibre, plus one or two strength sessions a week. She says this approach reduced body fat while preserving and gradually increasing muscle mass; no figures are given.
Limits. The account is the dietitian's, given in a feature on protein intake. The tool is not named, the generated plan is not reproduced, and the article does not say what the patient asked the tool or whether it was a chatbot or a diet application. The dates of the diet, the patient's age and the place are not stated. The muscle loss is not quantified.
Reported harm
In the dietitian's account, three months on the AI-generated meal plan left the patient with a loss of muscle mass shown by body-composition analysis and chronic constipation attributed to the plan's low fibre content.
Outcome
UnknownThe dietitian says she replaced the plan with a more balanced 1800 kcal diet with 120 g of protein, more whole grains, vegetables, plant protein and fibre, and one or two strength sessions a week. The dietitian says this approach allowed the patient to reduce body fat while preserving and gradually increasing muscle mass; the article gives no figures or timeframe for that result and no other follow-up.
What remains unknown
- The AI tool is not named, and the article does not say whether it was a chatbot or a diet application, or what the patient asked it.
- The generated plan is not reproduced; its composition is known only from the dietitian's description.
- The dates of the three-month diet and of the consultation are not stated; the patient's age and location are not stated.
- The muscle loss is not quantified, and no other possible causes of the constipation are discussed.
What the evidence supports
AI involvement: reported. The article states that the patient's meal plan was generated by an AI-based tool and gives what that plan prescribed: 1400 kcal and 140 g of protein a day at 72 kg, with carbohydrates, healthy fats and fibre cut to reach that level, and about 9 g of fibre a day. The dietitian connects that composition to the harm: the fibre level to the chronic constipation, and the low calories with high protein and no strength training to the muscle loss. The tool is not named, the plan is not reproduced, and the account is the dietitian's as quoted by one outlet.
4 claims: 4 reported. What the statuses mean
Reported A patient who consulted the dietitian to reduce body fat had for the previous three months followed a meal plan generated by an AI-based tool, which provided 1400 kcal and 140 g of protein a day at a body weight of 72 kg.
Causal attribution. The dietitian's description of the plan, quoted by Gazeta.pl. The plan itself is not reproduced and the tool is not named.
- kobieta.gazeta.pl(opens in new tab) supports · Polish
'Wcześniej przez trzy miesiące stosowała jadłospis wygenerowany przez narzędzie oparte na sztucznej inteligencji'; 'Dieta dostarczała 1400 kcal oraz 140 g białka dziennie przy masie ciała wynoszącej 72 kg'
Reported The dietitian says the plan did not take the patient's lifestyle into account (pilates two or three times a week, no strength training), that at so low a calorie level its very high protein came at the cost of carbohydrates, healthy fats and fibre, and that its quality was low with many processed protein products.
Causal attribution. The dietitian's professional assessment of the plan, as quoted.
- kobieta.gazeta.pl(opens in new tab) supports · Polish
'zalecenia nie uwzględniały stylu życia'; 'osiągnięcie bardzo wysokiej podaży białka odbyło się kosztem innych składników diety. Były to głównie węglowodany, zdrowe tłuszcze oraz błonnik pokarmowy'; 'jakość jadłospisu była niska'
Reported After three months on the plan the patient had lost 3.5 kg, body-composition analysis also showed a loss of muscle mass, and she had developed chronic constipation, which the dietitian attributes to a fibre intake of about 9 g a day against a recommended 25 to 30 g.
Causal attribution. The dietitian attributes the constipation to the plan's low fibre and presents the muscle loss as a result of the diet; the article offers no other cause.
- kobieta.gazeta.pl(opens in new tab) supports · Polish
'po trzech miesiącach restrykcyjnej diety schudła 3,5 kg. Analiza składu wykazała jednak również utratę masy mięśniowej'; 'u pacjentki pojawiły się przewlekłe zaparcia. Był to skutek niskiego spożycia błonnika'; 'Wynosiło zaledwie około 9 g dziennie, podczas gdy rekomendowana ilość to 25-30 g'
Reported The dietitian replaced the plan with an 1800 kcal diet with 120 g of protein, more whole grains, vegetables, plant protein and fibre, and recommended one or two strength sessions a week.
Causal attribution. The dietitian's description of her own response; she says the new plan reduced body fat while preserving and gradually increasing muscle mass, without figures.
- kobieta.gazeta.pl(opens in new tab) supports · Polish
'Ekspertka zaproponowała kobiecie bardziej zbilansowany model żywienia oparty na diecie 1800 kcal ze 120 g białka dziennie'; 'zaleciłam włączenie jednego lub dwóch treningów siłowych tygodniowo'; 'Jak podkreśla nasza rozmówczyni, takie podejście pozwoliło skutecznie zredukować tkankę tłuszczową przy jednoczesnym zachowaniu, a także stopniowym zwiększaniu masy mięśniowej'
Sources
1 source inspected. Sources that repeat one account do not corroborate each other.
- Gazeta.pl Kobieta, 5 October 2026: "Przeszła na dietę wygenerowaną przez AI. Poza kilogramami straciła coś jeszcze"(opens in new tab)
s1 · kobieta.gazeta.pl · National news · Polish · Inspected · 5 October 2026 · Primary
How the sources were read, and where the events happened
Read in Polish: the full article on kobieta.gazeta.pl. Passages were translated by the research agent, an AI; no human translator reviewed them. Applies to s1.
Event countries: Unknown. Affected-person countries: Unknown. Court countries: Unknown.
The article does not state where the patient lives or where the consultation took place. The outlet is Polish and the dietitian practises in Poland, but neither fact locates this patient's diet or consultation, so no country is recorded.
Reviewed for publication 2026-10-07: Published as a clinician's attributed account of one patient: the article states what the AI-generated plan prescribed and the dietitian connects that composition to the muscle loss and chronic constipation she found. Single source; claims are marked reported, the patient is unnamed, and the unknowns (tool, dates, place, quantification) are recorded.
People described
A woman who consulted a clinical dietitian after three months on an AI-generated meal plan; age not stated
People reported harmed in this case
1 person
1 AI participant · 0 other people harmed
One person: the patient the dietitian describes, who followed the AI-generated plan and developed the reported effects.
Counted once within this case. The same person may appear in other cases. This count does not establish AI causation.
Tags
Cite this case
Compiled per our published methodology: verification statuses, sourcing standards, and corrections process.
APA
NOPE. (2026). Dietitian says a patient who followed an AI-generated 1400 kcal meal plan for three months lost muscle and developed chronic constipation, Gazeta.pl reports. AI incidents. https://nope.net/incidents/2026-dietitian-reports-patient-ai-generated-meal-plan-muscle-loss-constipation
BibTeX
@misc{2026_dietitian_reports_patient_ai_generated_meal_plan_muscle_loss_constipation,
title = {Dietitian says a patient who followed an AI-generated 1400 kcal meal plan for three months lost muscle and developed chronic constipation, Gazeta.pl reports},
author = {NOPE},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {AI incidents},
url = {https://nope.net/incidents/2026-dietitian-reports-patient-ai-generated-meal-plan-muscle-loss-constipation}
} Related cases
Changsha hospital says man handled sudden dizziness as vertigo following an AI platform's prompts, stayed home three days and had a large cerebellar stroke
Xinmin Evening News reported on 25 June 2026 that Changsha Central Hospital treated a 52-year-old man who had sudden dizziness at home on 18 June. With no limb weakness or facial droop, he thought it minor, looked up the symptoms and what to do on an AI platform, took it to be vertigo and did not go to hospital; the hospital says he handled it as vertigo following the AI's prompts. Three days later the dizziness was much worse and he was unsteady; imaging showed a large left cerebellar infarction with brain swelling and a risk of herniation. He came through the critical phase after treatment. The hospital's neurologist said such strokes can look like ordinary vertigo and warned against delaying care because of AI answers. The AI platform is not named.
Wuhan, China: reports say a family ate wild mushrooms an AI identification tool called non-poisonous and a 9-year-old fell critically ill; one cites amatoxin
A family from Wuhan, Hubei province, gathered wild mushrooms resembling the edible termite mushroom (jizong) during a mountain outing in June 2026 and, according to a Guangming Online post carried by The Paper on 5 July 2026 and an Asahi Shimbun report of 6 July citing the Changjiang Daily, ran an AI identification tool on them. The tool returned a "non-poisonous" result and the family cooked and ate the mushrooms. According to the Guangming Online post, all three family members vomited soon after the meal and again before dawn the next day; they were admitted to Zhongnan Hospital of Wuhan University, where the 9-year-old child was moved to the paediatric intensive care unit the same afternoon. The post says the child had amatoxin poisoning that progressed to the most severe grade, with acute liver failure, hepatic encephalopathy and fluid in the chest and abdomen, and went home after eight days in hospital. The AI tool is not named, its output is not reproduced, and the account comes from one reporting chain.
Chengdu hospital says man who followed an AI-made weight-loss plan lost 20 kg in 45 days, then developed sepsis with multi-organ failure
On 5 August 2026 Upstream News and Chengdu Daily's Jinguan News relayed a Chengdu hospital's account of a 34-year-old man who used an AI tool to plan a rapid weight loss. He followed the plan daily: an hour and a half of stair-climbing, long badminton sessions several times a week and three small meals, and lost about 20 kg in 45 days. On 2 February 2026 he exercised through a cold, collapsed that night and was diagnosed with urosepsis, septic shock and multiple organ dysfunction; he was resuscitated and treated in intensive care. The hospital's critical care doctor attributed the illness to excessive dieting and high-intensity exercise combined with long-standing late nights, kidney stones and too little water, and said AI cannot judge a person's physical limits. He was left with myocarditis, recurring kidney stones and hair loss. The AI product is not named.
Hangzhou hospital says a man took three times the standard antiviral dose after AI advice gave tablet counts, not grams, and developed acute kidney injury
Zhejiang Provincial Tongde Hospital in Hangzhou told Red Star News (relayed by China News Service on 26 January 2026) that a patient with a cold sore had recently used AI online to look up treatment, bought valaciclovir and took it as advised. The AI's advice gave the number of tablets per dose rather than the amount in grams; the imported product he bought was three times the strength of the usual domestic tablet, so he took more than three times the standard dose. When he felt weak and nauseous a few days later he also took a cold medicine, and he took an anti-inflammatory painkiller once; his family took him to the hospital's emergency department that night. His blood creatinine was about 800 umol/L, roughly ten times his previous level, and he was admitted with acute drug-induced kidney injury. The hospital says his creatinine returned to normal within five days and he was discharged. The AI tool and its exact wording are not identified.
If you or someone you know is struggling, free and confidential support is available. Find a helpline near you at Signpost.