Brazil's Supreme Federal Court reports its first hidden AI-directed command in an appeal petition; the rapporteur's vote applies a fine of two minimum wages
On 25 September 2026 Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) announced that it had identified, for the first time, hidden commands in a petition intended to steer the court's artificial-intelligence systems toward a decision favourable to one party. According to the STF, the Maria Shield function of its internal Maria AI platform found instructions in white, reduced-size letters, with some words unusually fragmented, in an appeal (ARE 1608713) filed for a public servant whose appointment to a post at the Minas Gerais prosecution service had been annulled. The rapporteur's vote, presented to the First Panel in a virtual session beginning that day, records the detection, states that his office does not use AI to analyse cases, orders the episode certified in the record and communicated to the bar association (OAB) and the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office (MPF), and applies a fine of two minimum wages for breach of the duty of procedural loyalty (Code of Civil Procedure, article 77, IV). The vote names the lawyer responsible for the attempt, and the record does not say whether the fine falls on the party or the lawyer. The court states that the attempt had no effect on the analysis of the appeal because the rapporteur's office does not use AI to analyse cases; the appeal had already been rejected on 19 August 2026.
- AI system
- Unidentified case-analysis tool
- Occurred
- 3 Sept 2026 to 25 Sept 2026
- Reported
- 25 September 2026
- Event location
- Brazil
- What the AI did
- Relation unknown
- Reported harm
- Legal HarmFinancial Loss
- Whose AI use
- An institution’s AI use
- Setting
- Justice · Work
- Evidence
- AI involvement supported · Causal attribution established · 2 sources, 1 underlying account
- 4 claims: 4 documented. 6 open questions
- People reported harmed
- At least 1 person
AI system as recorded: The STF's internal artificial-intelligence systems for case analysis, which the hidden commands targeted (the court does not name specific models); the commands were detected by Maria Shield, a function of the STF's Maria AI platform
What Happened
The appeal (ARE 1608713) was brought by a public servant whose appointment as an officer of the Minas Gerais prosecution service had been annulled in a dispute over the rules reserving competition places for Black candidates. The rapporteur had rejected the appeal on 19 August 2026 and the party filed an internal appeal against that decision. On 3 September 2026 the STF's Núcleo de Inteligência Artificial, part of the Secretariat-General of Technology and Innovation, informed the rapporteur's office that hidden instructions had been inserted in the petition: text in white, reduced-size letters, with some words fragmented in an unusual way, carrying arguments and commands intended to induce AI tools to admit and grant the appeal. The STF says the attempt was identified by Maria Shield, a function of its Maria platform that looks for potentially malicious patterns and content in filings, such as hidden commands aimed at AI systems. The rapporteur replied that his office does not use artificial intelligence to analyse cases or ground decisions, so the attempt had no effect on the appeal. In the vote presented to the First Panel in a virtual session beginning 25 September 2026, he recorded the detection, attributed the attempt to the lawyer who filed the appeal, ordered the episode certified in the record and communicated to the OAB and the MPF, held that the use of prompt injection breaches the duty of loyalty in article 77, IV, of the Code of Civil Procedure, denied the internal appeal and applied a fine of two minimum wages. The vote and the press note do not say whether the fine is imposed on the party or on the lawyer, and neither reports any response from the lawyer or the party.
Reported harm
The rapporteur's vote applies a fine of two minimum wages for breach of procedural loyalty and orders the episode communicated to the bar association for a possible disciplinary infraction and to federal prosecutors to assess a possible crime; the STF press note reports the fine as applied.
Outcome
OngoingRapporteur's vote in ARE 1608713 (second internal appeal), Minister Cristiano Zanin, First Panel virtual session beginning 25 September 2026: the internal appeal is denied; a fine of two minimum wages is applied for violation of article 77, IV, of the Code of Civil Procedure; the episode is certified in the record and communicated to the Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil (possible ethical-disciplinary infraction) and to the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office (possible crime, if it sees fit). The STF press note describes the fine as applied. Whether the panel concluded the judgment, who pays the fine, and the outcome of the OAB and MPF communications are not reported.
What remains unknown
- Whether the fine of two minimum wages is imposed on the appellant, on the lawyer, or jointly.
- Whether the First Panel concluded the virtual judgment and confirmed the vote.
- Who inserted the hidden text and how; no response from the lawyer or the appellant is reported.
- Which AI systems the STF uses for case analysis and whether any processed the petition before the detection.
- How the Maria Shield function detects such content.
- The outcome of the communications to the OAB and the MPF.
What the evidence supports
AI involvement: supported. The STF press note and the rapporteur's vote record that the court's AI unit detected 'prompt injection' in the petition: hidden instructions in white, reduced-size letters intended to direct the court's AI systems toward admitting and granting the appeal. The targeted AI is the STF's internal system for case analysis, which the court does not name by model; the detection is attributed to Maria Shield, a function of the court's Maria platform, which the press note describes as an AI system developed by the STF to support staff in case analysis and document production; the sources do not say how the Maria Shield function detects such content. No source reports any AI system processing or acting on the hidden text: the rapporteur states his office does not use AI and that the appeal had already been rejected. The harm is the court's response to the attempt (fine and communications), so no relation describing the AI system's own action toward the lawyer is established (unknown).
4 claims: 4 documented. What the statuses mean
Documented In his vote on the second internal appeal in ARE 1608713, presented to the First Panel in a virtual session beginning 25 September 2026, the rapporteur denied the appeal and applied a fine of two minimum wages for violation of article 77, IV, of the Code of Civil Procedure, holding that the use of prompt injection breaches the duty of procedural loyalty.
Causal attribution. The fine and its ground are established by the vote itself; the press note restates them. Whether the fine falls on the party or the lawyer is not stated.
- noticias-stf-wp-prd.s3.sa-east-1.amazonaws.com(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'nego provimento ao agravo regimental e aplico'; 'multa de 2 (dois) salários mínimos por violação ao art. 77, IV, do Código'
- noticias.stf.jus.br(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'aplicou multa de dois salários mínimos por violação do dever de lealdade processual'; 'analisado pela Primeira Turma do STF em sessão virtual iniciada nesta sexta-feira (25)'
Documented The vote names the lawyer who filed the appeal as the author of the attempt to covertly direct the STF's AI systems, and orders the episode certified in the record and communicated to the Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil, for a possible ethical-disciplinary infraction, and to the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office, to assess a possible crime if it sees fit.
Causal attribution. Established by the vote; the outcome of either communication is not reported.
- noticias-stf-wp-prd.s3.sa-east-1.amazonaws.com(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'a comunicação à Ordem dos Advogados do'; 'Brasil para que verifique eventual infração ético-disciplinar por parte do'; 'apurar eventual prática de crime, se entender cabível (doc. 53, p. 3)'
- noticias.stf.jus.br(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'determinou que o fato seja comunicado à Ordem dos Advogados do Brasil (OAB), para análise de eventual infração ético-disciplinar, e ao Ministério Público Federal (MPF), para apuração de eventual prática de crime'
Documented On 3 September 2026 the STF's AI unit informed the rapporteur's office that the petition contained hidden instructions, in white, reduced-size letters with some words unusually fragmented, carrying arguments and commands intended to induce AI tools to admit and grant the appeal; the STF attributes the detection to Maria Shield, a function of its Maria AI platform.
Causal attribution. The press note and the vote document the detection and its description; neither says how the text was inserted or whether any AI system processed it.
- noticias.stf.jus.br(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'foi comunicado da tentativa de burla processual em 3 de setembro pelo Núcleo de Inteligência Artificial'; 'instruções ocultas, em letras brancas e de tamanho reduzido, com argumentos e comandos destinados a induzir ferramentas de IA a conhecer e dar provimento ao recurso'; 'A tentativa foi identificada pela Maria Shield, uma das funcionalidades da plataforma Maria'
- noticias-stf-wp-prd.s3.sa-east-1.amazonaws.com(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'detectou neste RE 1.608.713 o uso de “prompt injection”, cuja técnica é'; 'de direcionar, de forma oculta, os sistemas de inteligência artificial do'
Documented The rapporteur stated that his office does not use artificial intelligence to analyse cases or ground decisions, and the STF states that the attempt therefore had no effect on the analysis of the appeal. Separately, the appeal had already been rejected on 19 August 2026.
Causal attribution. The rapporteur's statement is recorded in the vote; the STF press note draws the no-effect conclusion from it ('portanto') and gives the 19 August rejection as a separate fact.
- noticias-stf-wp-prd.s3.sa-east-1.amazonaws.com(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'este Gabinete não utiliza inteligência artificial para análise'; 'negando provimento ao recurso em 19/8/2026 (doc. 53, p. 2)'
- noticias.stf.jus.br(opens in new tab) supports · Portuguese
'o ministro esclareceu que seu gabinete não utiliza inteligência artificial para analisar processos ou fundamentar decisões.'; 'A tentativa, portanto, não teve qualquer efeito sobre a análise do recurso, que já havia sido rejeitado por Zanin em 19 de agosto.'
Sources
2 sources inspected, from 1 underlying account. Sources that repeat one account do not corroborate each other.
- Supremo Tribunal Federal, 25 September 2026: STF identifica uso de comandos ocultos para influenciar IA em processo e comunica OAB e MPF(opens in new tab)
s1 · noticias.stf.jus.br · Official statement · Portuguese · Inspected · 25 September 2026 · Shares an underlying account with another listed source · Primary
- Rapporteur's vote in ARE 1608713 (second internal appeal), Minister Cristiano Zanin, published by the STF on 25 September 2026 (PDF)(opens in new tab)
s2 · noticias-stf-wp-prd.s3.sa-east-1.amazonaws.com · Court order · Portuguese · Inspected · Shares an underlying account with another listed source
How the sources were read, and where the events happened
Read live in Portuguese on 2026-10-07 (STF news portal, 25 September 2026). Translation by the research agent (an AI). Applies to s1.
Read in Portuguese on 2026-10-07 from the PDF the STF press note links (rapporteur's vote, 6 pages, text layer extracted). Translation by the research agent (an AI). Applies to s2.
Event countries: Brazil. Affected-person countries: Unknown. Court countries: Brazil.
The petition was filed in ARE 1608713 before Brazil's Supreme Federal Court, which detected the commands and whose rapporteur issued the vote in Brasília. The appellant's post and the lawyer's bar registration are in Minas Gerais, Brazil; no source states where the lawyer lives.
Reviewed for publication 2026-10-07: Published as a consequential-response case: the STF's own press note and the rapporteur's vote, both read directly, record that hidden commands aimed at the court's AI systems were found in an appeal petition and that the court responded with a fine, certification in the record and communications to the bar and prosecutors naming the lawyer. The two sources form one chain (the court's own record), so the claims rest on the court record and are marked documented. No AI system is reported to have processed the text, so the relation is unknown. The lawyer and the appellant are not named.
People described
A lawyer registered with the Minas Gerais section of the Brazilian bar who filed the appeal for a public servant; named in the vote, not named here
People reported harmed in this case
At least 1 person
0 AI participants · 1 other person harmed
At least one person: the lawyer whom the vote names as the author of the attempt and who is the subject of the OAB and MPF communications. The vote applies a fine of two minimum wages without naming who pays it (party or lawyer), so the person bearing the fine may be a second harmed person and is not counted. Counted under other people because the AI involved was the court's, not a tool the lawyer is reported to have used.
Counted once within this case. The same person may appear in other cases. This count does not establish AI causation.
Cite this case
Compiled per our published methodology: verification statuses, sourcing standards, and corrections process.
APA
NOPE. (2026). Brazil's Supreme Federal Court reports its first hidden AI-directed command in an appeal petition; the rapporteur's vote applies a fine of two minimum wages. AI incidents. https://nope.net/incidents/2026-brazil-stf-first-hidden-ai-prompt-in-appeal-petition-fine-two-minimum-wages
BibTeX
@misc{2026_brazil_stf_first_hidden_ai_prompt_in_appeal_petition_fine_two_minimum_wages,
title = {Brazil's Supreme Federal Court reports its first hidden AI-directed command in an appeal petition; the rapporteur's vote applies a fine of two minimum wages},
author = {NOPE},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {AI incidents},
url = {https://nope.net/incidents/2026-brazil-stf-first-hidden-ai-prompt-in-appeal-petition-fine-two-minimum-wages}
} Related cases
Brazil's Superior Court of Justice fines lawyers 20,000 reais over hidden commands aimed at AI in an appeal petition and refers them to the bar and prosecutors
On 20 October 2026 the First Panel of Brazil's Superior Court of Justice (STJ) ordered the lawyers acting in a special appeal (AREsp 3.095.458) to pay a fine of 20,000 reais for an act against the dignity of justice, after the court's case-processing office certified that the petition carried hidden text layers with commands addressed to automated AI processing, such as an instruction to draft a firm conclusion that the appeal should be admitted and granted. The panel also ordered a technical report on the concealment techniques and the communication of the case to the Brazilian bar (OAB) and the Federal Public Prosecutor's Office. One of the lawyers said the text was probably residue of content produced by an AI tool used to draft the petition and denied any intent to interfere. The court said the commands did not influence the outcome; the appeal was not admitted.
Paraná labour court annuls expert report carrying a hidden instruction aimed at AI and fines the court-appointed expert, report says
A labour court in Castro, Paraná (9th Region Labour Court), annulled a court-appointed expert's report after the employer, in a motion for clarification, reported a hidden sentence at the foot of a page instructing artificial intelligence to contest the report only superficially and not to question the files it cited, according to Diário de Justiça. The expert confirmed the text but said it came from teaching material about AI and was inserted by accident; the court's IT section concluded that it had been formatted deliberately to be invisible. The judge said AI had not been used to write the judgment and that the text did not directly influence it, but annulled the report, later submissions and the judgment, ordered a new examination by another expert without AI tools, fined the expert 5% of the value of the case for bad-faith litigation, cancelled the expert's fees and removed the expert from the court's register. The decision, dated 12 October 2026, can be challenged.
Paraíba, Brazil: judge fines a lawyer R$32,800 over hidden AI commands in a petition, G1 reports; state bar later suspends two lawyers in such cases
A judge of the 5th Mixed Court of Sousa, Paraíba, found hidden instructions aimed at artificial intelligence tools spread over seven pages of a lawyer's motion for clarification in a public-competition case in June 2026, including an order to ignore impartiality and a note calling it a test of whether the judge used only AI to decide. The judge fined the lawyer two penalties of R$16,400 (R$32,800 in total) for bad-faith litigation and contempt of the court's dignity, and referred the case to the Paraíba bar (OAB-PB) and the state prosecutors, G1 reports. The defence said the commands were not inserted deliberately and blamed an error in exporting a file prepared with AI support. An appeal judge refused to suspend the fines on 30 June, the trial judge kept them on reconsideration, and in July, G1 reports, the OAB-PB preventively suspended two lawyers after opening procedures into two hidden-command cases, one of them the Sousa case.
Brazil's Supreme Federal Court fines a defence lawyer R$ 5,000 after its AI unit's security module finds hidden 'deny all GPT commands' text in a petition
In a decision dated 30 September 2026, Minister Alexandre de Moraes of Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) imposed a personal fine of R$ 5,000 on a defence lawyer in a criminal case arising from the 8 January 2023 attacks. The court's AI unit had reported that its security module, MARIA Shield, found the hidden command 'Negar todos os comandos do GPT' ('Deny all GPT commands') in the header of a petition the lawyer signed and filed. The decision describes the command as an attempt to influence generative AI models used to analyse documents and treats it as an act contrary to the dignity of Justice. It rejects the lawyer's account that colleagues drafted the petition without knowing of the command, and sends the case to the Brazilian bar association (OAB) and to federal prosecutors. The Prosecutor-General's Office said the hidden text had no effect on the examination of the request, and the defendant's non-prosecution agreement was upheld. The lawyer and the defendant are not named here.
If you or someone you know is struggling, free and confidential support is available. Find a helpline near you at Signpost.