Police in New Mexico handcuffed two sisters, one a child, after a Flock plate camera misread a digit and flagged their car as stolen, lawsuits say; settled 2025
On 23 July 2023 Española police officers pulled over a car driven by a 21-year-old woman with her 12-year-old sister as a passenger, after a Flock Safety camera at an intersection flagged the car's plate as belonging to a vehicle stolen in Rio Rancho. According to the sisters' lawsuits, reported by the Santa Fe New Mexican in January 2024, the camera had read a 2 on the plate as a 7, and officers handcuffed both sisters and placed them in the backs of separate police vehicles before discovering the error; the older sister had asked an officer to call their mother, who lived nearby, to collect the girl. The suits sought damages for anxiety, fear, worry and restriction of movement. Business Insider, which reviewed the body-camera footage and incident report, reported in March 2026 that officers said the number was obscured by a license plate cover although it is visible in the footage, and that the family settled with the city in 2025.
- AI system
- Flock Safety license plate readers
- Flock Safety
- Occurred
- 23 Jul 2023
- Reported
- 8 January 2024
- Event location
- United States
- What the AI did
- Made a claim about the person
- Reported harm
- Loss of LibertyPsychological Distress
- Whose AI use
- An institution’s AI use
- Setting
- Justice
- Evidence
- AI involvement supported · Causal attribution supported · 2 sources
- 5 claims: 2 corroborated, 1 disputed, 2 reported. 3 open questions
- People reported harmed
- 2 people
AI system as recorded: Flock Safety automated license-plate-reader camera at an Española intersection (described by Business Insider as one of Flock's AI cameras) that misread the car's plate, matched it to a stolen-vehicle record and notified police
What Happened
The Santa Fe New Mexican (8 January 2024) reported two lawsuits against the city of Española. According to the suits, Española police officers pulled the sisters over on 23 July 2023 on Calle Duran after the car passed an intersection equipped with a Flock Safety camera, which incorrectly flagged its plate as belonging to a vehicle stolen in Rio Rancho; the plate was one digit different, ending in a 2 that the camera read as a 7. Officers handcuffed both sisters and placed them in the backs of police vehicles before discovering the error; the older sister asked an officer to call their mother to pick up the 12-year-old, and officers instead handcuffed the girl and put her in a different police vehicle. The suits sought damages including compensation for anxiety, fear, worry and restriction of movement. The city, its police chief and Flock did not respond to the newspaper. Business Insider (9 March 2026), reviewing body-camera footage and an incident report, reported that Flock notified police that the car was stolen, that officers ordered the sisters out and handcuffed them, that the incident report says the camera misread a 2 as a 7 and that officers said a plate cover obscured the number although it is visible in the footage, and that the family settled with the city in 2025.
Reported harm
Both sisters, one of them 12, were handcuffed and held in the backs of police vehicles after the misread alert; their lawsuits claimed anxiety, fear, worry and restriction of movement (Santa Fe New Mexican). The family settled with the city in 2025 (Business Insider).
Outcome
ResolvedThe older sister filed suit against the city of Española in state district court on 3 January 2024, and their mother filed a separate complaint on the younger sister's behalf (Santa Fe New Mexican). Business Insider reports that the family settled with the city in 2025; settlement terms were not reported.
What remains unknown
- Settlement terms and date in 2025.
- The state district court case numbers; the complaints were not read.
- How long the sisters were held before officers found the error.
What the evidence supports
AI involvement: supported. The sisters' lawsuits (Santa Fe New Mexican) say a Flock Safety camera incorrectly flagged the plate as belonging to a stolen vehicle, reading a 2 as a 7; Business Insider reports the incident report records the same misread and describes the cameras as Flock's AI cameras. The plate match against a stolen-vehicle record is the automated system's claim about the car; the decision to handcuff both sisters was the officers'.
5 claims: 2 corroborated, 1 disputed, 2 reported. What the statuses mean
Corroborated In July 2023 Española police stopped the sisters' car after a Flock camera alert identified it as stolen, and officers ordered both sisters out and handcuffed them, including the 12-year-old.
Causal attribution. The lawsuits as reported, and Business Insider's separate review of the body-camera footage.
- santafenewmexican.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'pulled the sisters over July 23 on Calle Duran after they had passed through an intersection equipped with a Flock Safety camera, which incorrectly flagged their car’s license plate as belonging to a stolen vehicle, according to the lawsuits.'; 'officers pulled the vehicle over and handcuffed them before placing them in the back of police vehicles prior to discovering the error.'
- businessinsider.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'when Flock notified police that her Kia was stolen.'; 'Body camera footage from the July 2023 stop shows officers stopping the sisters and ordering them to exit the car, before handcuffing them.'
Corroborated The camera misread a 2 on the plate as a 7.
Causal attribution. The sisters' complaint (as reported by the Santa Fe New Mexican) and the police incident report (as reported by Business Insider) agree on the misread.
- santafenewmexican.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'The plate number ended in 2, which the camera incorrectly read as 7, according to the complaint.'
- businessinsider.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'According to an incident report, the camera misread a "2" for a "7."'
Reported The sisters' lawsuits sought damages including compensation for anxiety, fear, worry and restriction of movement; the older sister had asked an officer to call their mother to collect the 12-year-old, and officers instead handcuffed the girl.
Causal attribution. The sisters' complaints as reported.
- santafenewmexican.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'compensation for personal injuries including “anxiety, fear, worry and restriction of movement.”'; 'Instead, officers handcuffed the girl and put her in the back of a different police vehicle, according to the complaint.'
Reported The family filed lawsuits against the city of Española and settled with the city in 2025.
Causal attribution. Filing reported by the Santa Fe New Mexican; settlement reported by Business Insider without terms.
- santafenewmexican.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'Two Rio Arriba County sisters have filed lawsuits against the city of Española'
- businessinsider.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'The family filed a lawsuit and settled with the city in 2025.'
Disputed Officers said a license plate cover obscured the number; Business Insider says the number is visible in the body-camera footage it reviewed.
Causal attribution. Officers' explanation as reported by Business Insider, contradicted by Business Insider's own review of the footage.
- businessinsider.com(opens in new tab) supports · English
'Officers said the number was obscured by a license plate cover, though it'
Sources
2 sources inspected. Sources that repeat one account do not corroborate each other.
- Santa Fe New Mexican, 8 January 2024: Sisters sue Española over traffic stop they say was illegal(opens in new tab)
s1 · santafenewmexican.com · News report · English · Inspected · 8 January 2024 · Primary
- Business Insider, 9 March 2026: 'Flock Flocked up'(opens in new tab)
s2 · businessinsider.com · News report · English · Inspected · 9 March 2026
How the sources were read, and where the events happened
Read on 2026-10-04 from the Internet Archive 2026 capture (Santa Fe New Mexican, 8 January 2024); the live site returned HTTP 429. Reports the two complaints and the attorney's comments. Applies to s1.
Read live on 2026-10-04 (Business Insider, 9 March 2026); full text present in the served page. Draws on its own review of body-camera footage and the incident report. Applies to s2.
Event countries: United States. Affected-person countries: United States. Court countries: United States.
The stop took place on Calle Duran in Española, New Mexico; the sisters are from Rio Arriba County, and the suits were filed in New Mexico state district court (Santa Fe New Mexican).
Reviewed for publication 2026-10-04: Published under the 2026-09-15 charter as an institutional-use case consistent with the held Flock misread rows: the sisters' lawsuits (Santa Fe New Mexican) and the police incident report and body-camera footage reviewed by Business Insider describe a Flock license-plate-camera misread that led officers to handcuff a 21-year-old and her 12-year-old sister. Neither sister is named here.
People described
Two sisters from Rio Arriba County, New Mexico: the 21-year-old driver and owner of the car, and her 12-year-old sister, a passenger
People reported harmed in this case
2 people
0 AI participants · 2 other people harmed
Two people, the sisters, both handcuffed and placed in police vehicles (Santa Fe New Mexican; Business Insider). Exact 2.
Counted once within this case. The same person may appear in other cases. This count does not establish AI causation.
Tags
Cite this case
Compiled per our published methodology: verification statuses, sourcing standards, and corrections process.
APA
NOPE. (2026). Police in New Mexico handcuffed two sisters, one a child, after a Flock plate camera misread a digit and flagged their car as stolen, lawsuits say; settled 2025. AI incidents. https://nope.net/incidents/2023-espanola-new-mexico-flock-alpr-misread-plate-sisters-handcuffed-lawsuits
BibTeX
@misc{2023_espanola_new_mexico_flock_alpr_misread_plate_sisters_handcuffed_lawsuits,
title = {Police in New Mexico handcuffed two sisters, one a child, after a Flock plate camera misread a digit and flagged their car as stolen, lawsuits say; settled 2025},
author = {NOPE},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {AI incidents},
url = {https://nope.net/incidents/2023-espanola-new-mexico-flock-alpr-misread-plate-sisters-handcuffed-lawsuits}
} Related cases
Morristown, Tennessee: police held a grandmother and grandfather at gunpoint and handcuffed them in June 2025, with their 3-year-old granddaughter left in the car, after a Flock alert flagged the grandmother's vanity plate, which matched a recovered stolen pickup's plate spelled with a zero; police say the stop rested on the crime database
In June 2025 Morristown, Tennessee, police stopped a couple driving their 3-year-old granddaughter to a doctor's appointment, held them at gunpoint and handcuffed them both. The grandmother's personalized plate spelled a nickname with the letter O; a Ford F-150 reported stolen in Claiborne County carried the same word spelled with a zero. Business Insider reported in March 2026 that officers received a Flock alert that the plate was stolen, that the Flock investigative summary recorded the couple's plate with a zero, and that the stolen pickup had already been recovered but was never removed from the system. The police department told WATE that the officer ran the tag as displayed, with an O, and that with either character it showed as stolen in the crime information database; the police chief told Business Insider that officers relied on the National Crime Information Center as protocol requires. The grandfather told WATE that he thought he might be shot and felt humiliated, and the grandmother said she was crying as she heard her granddaughter calling for her.
Toledo, Ohio: police stopped a man's pickup at gunpoint in April 2024 after a Flock license-plate camera misread his plate as stolen, released a police dog that bit him, and charged him; prosecutors dropped the charges and he later settled a lawsuit for $35,000
On 11 April 2024 Toledo police officers stopped a pickup truck after a Flock license-plate camera alerted them to a stolen plate. According to the police report and body-camera footage reported by 13abc and ABC News, the camera had misread the plate, which was not stolen. Officers drew their guns, ordered the driver out and to the ground, and a K-9 handler released a police dog as he began to kneel. The driver told ABC News he was bitten seven times on his forearm and elbow, was traumatized and could not work; he was arrested and charged with obstruction, resisting arrest and, later, failure to comply. Prosecutors dropped all charges in August 2024. The department found the dog deployment within policy and reprimanded the officer who made the stop for failing to visually verify the plate against the reader's information. Business Insider reported in March 2026 that police records show the camera read a 7 on the plate as a 2, that the man lost feeling in his fingers, gave up his lawn-care business and forklift work, sold his truck and was evicted, and that he had sued the officer and the city and settled in October for $35,000.
York County, South Carolina: Iraq War veteran Steven Melvin says deputies held him at gunpoint and made him kneel for more than five minutes outside his Lake Wylie apartment complex in February 2024 after a Flock license-plate reader misread his plate and flagged his BMW as stolen; he sued in June 2026
According to a lawsuit filed on 29 June 2026 and reported by The Herald (Rock Hill), a York County sheriff's deputy stopped Steven Melvin, 42, on 14 February 2024 as he pulled into his apartment complex near Lake Wylie, after receiving a Flock license-plate-reader alert that a stolen dark-coloured BMW sedan was in the area. The deputy approached Melvin's black BMW with his gun drawn and aimed at him and made him kneel with his hands over his head for more than five minutes; after calling for backup and checking his information, the deputy determined the car was not stolen. The camera had read the first letter of his South Carolina tag incorrectly, matching a stolen BMW one letter off. A sheriff's internal-affairs review in November 2024 found the deputy's actions reasonable and blamed an illegally tinted plate cover, for which Melvin received a verbal warning; an email cited in the filing says the cameras had read his plate correctly 13 times that month. Melvin says the stop caused him trauma and emotional distress. The sheriff's office removed the case to federal court in August 2026 and denies violating his rights.
Kansas couple pulled over twice after Flock license-plate cameras matched their KU alumni plate number to a stolen pickup's temporary tag; in Catoosa, Oklahoma, officers held them at gunpoint and handcuffed the husband, KAKE reported in January 2024
KAKE News reported on 30 January 2024 that a Kansas couple whose minivan carries a four-digit University of Kansas alumni specialty plate were pulled over twice after Flock cameras flagged their plate number as belonging to a stolen vehicle. A stolen GMC pickup had a temporary tag with the same number, and the stolen-vehicle entry recorded the wrong plate type. In Colwich, Kansas, police stopped the wife after an alert from a Flock camera at the edge of town; the officer knew her vehicle and the problem was quickly found. About a month later, according to the husband, another Flock camera alerted police in Catoosa, Oklahoma, where officers blocked the couple's van in a parking lot, pointed drawn guns at them, ordered the husband out and onto his knees and handcuffed him. He said he was scared, and the couple say they worry such a stop could have devastating consequences for someone. Wichita police told KAKE that Flock cameras report only the plate's numbers and letters, not its type, and that the department had spoken with Flock about training its AI to recognize plate backgrounds.
If you or someone you know is struggling, free and confidential support is available. Find a helpline near you at Signpost.