{"meta":{"exportedAt":"2026-11-18T10:19:20.075Z","formatVersion":2,"selection":{"q":"public-services","system":"","harm":"","context":"","country":"","role":"","relation":"","evidence":"","year":"2021","response":"","severity":"","verification":"","view":"incidents","sort":"added"},"totalIncidents":2,"coverage":{"cases":2,"countries":2,"languages":1,"unknownLocation":0,"locationPending":0,"unknownLanguage":0,"unknownDate":0,"lawsuits":0,"regulatory":0,"minors":0,"coreRelations":0,"contextualRelations":2,"mixedRelations":0,"unknownRelations":0,"relationPending":0,"relationUnknown":0},"countingNote":"Distinct public cases in this selection. People counts apply within individual cases only; cross-case person overlap has not been resolved. No population incidence estimate.","affectedCountNote":"Interpret person counts with affectedCountStatus and the reported effects. Unquantified zeros are placeholders, not a measured zero.","source":"AI incidents","publisher":"NOPE","url":"https://nope.net/incidents","license":"CC BY 4.0"},"incidents":[{"id":"2021-nevada-unemployment-claimant-says-id-me-face-check-rejected-him-and-locked-him-out-of-benefits","caseFacts":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"which uses a combination of biometric information and official documents to confirm that applicants are who they claim to be.; ID.me CEO Blake Hall told Motherboard that the company’s facial recognition technology does one-to-one matching—comparing one face against a picture of that same face (from a driver’s license, say); At least 21 states use ID.me to detect fraudulent benefit claims.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"ID.me verifies the identity of people claiming unemployment benefits in at least 21 US states, using biometric information and official documents, including a facial recognition step that compares one face with a picture of that same face, such as from a driving licence.","causal_attribution":"Motherboard's description and ID.me's chief executive's account of the system."},{"id":"c2","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"a gig economy worker in Las Vegas who was suddenly cut off from his unemployment benefits in late March after ID.me failed to identify him.; it rejected it, didn’t give us a reason, just rejected it. It rejected it three times, and then it locked me out of the system.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"A gig economy worker in Las Vegas says he was suddenly cut off from his unemployment benefits in late March 2021 after ID.me failed to identify him; he says the facial recognition test rejected him three times without giving a reason and then locked him out of the system.","causal_attribution":"The claimant's account to Motherboard; the year comes from the article's date of 18 June 2021."},{"id":"c3","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"He tried contacting the state of Nevada for help, but the employees there directed him back to ID.me.; until he tweeted a scathing criticism of the company, which then reached out and—after several more frustrating days—verified","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"The claimant says ID.me's chat support did not resolve the problem despite many attempts and the state of Nevada directed him back to ID.me; after several weeks he posted a public criticism, and the company contacted him and, after several more days, verified his identity.","causal_attribution":"The claimant's account as reported by Motherboard."},{"id":"c4","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"went for three weeks without receiving his benefit. “I couldn’t pay bills,”","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"The claimant says he went three weeks without his benefit and could not pay bills.","causal_attribution":"The claimant's own statement to Motherboard."},{"id":"c5","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"“The algorithms used for Face Match operate ~99.9% efficacy,” Hall wrote in an email to Motherboard.; Hall said that facial recognition failures are not a problem with the technology but with the people using it to verify their identity.; “We are unaware of eligible individuals who have not been able to verify their identity with ID.me,”","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"ID.me chief Blake Hall blamed the problems on users rather than the technology. Face Match algorithms have \"99.9% efficacy,","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"ID.me's chief executive told Motherboard that its Face Match algorithms operate at about 99.9% efficacy, that face-match failures are a problem with the people using the system rather than the technology, and that the company was unaware of eligible individuals unable to verify their identity.","causal_attribution":"ID.me's response, kept as counterevidence; Engadget relays the same statement."},{"id":"c6","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"ID.me unsurprisingly took issue with the Motherboard piece in a response provided to Engadget. Hall called the fraud claims \"inaccurate and defamatory,\" and stressed that the company suck to National Institute of Standards and Technology standards for identification. He reiterated the claims made about the nature of the facial recognition system and the video chat backup","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"In a response to Engadget, ID.me called Motherboard's fraud claims inaccurate and defamatory and repeated its account of the facial recognition system and its video chat backup.","causal_attribution":"ID.me's statement to Engadget."}],"effects":[{"label":"claimant says the face check rejected and locked him out, stopping his benefits for three weeks","claim_id":"c2","direction":"negative"}],"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.vice.com/en/article/facial-recognition-failures-are-locking-people-out-of-unemployment-systems/","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"en","translation_note":"Read in English on 2026-10-30; no translation.","independence_group":"motherboard-2021-06-18"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.engadget.com/facial-recognition-failures-id-me-unemployment-benefits-172654494.html","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"en","translation_note":"Read in English on 2026-10-30; no translation.","independence_group":"engadget-2021-06-19"}],"version":1,"ai_roles":["institutional_use"],"contexts":["public_services","finance"],"unknowns":["The exact dates of the lockout and of the verification; Motherboard gives only late March and three weeks without the benefit.","Why the face match failed in this case: no analysis of the attempts is reported, and ID.me attributes failures in general to users' photos.","Whether the missed benefit weeks were later paid."],"geography":{"basis":"The benefits were Nevada unemployment benefits: the claimant says he sought help from the state of Nevada, which sent him back to ID.me. Motherboard describes him as a gig economy worker in Las Vegas.","court_countries":[],"event_countries":["US"],"affected_person_countries":["US"]},"publication":{"basis":"Published as a state unemployment system's facial recognition identity check rejecting a described claimant three times and locking him out, which he says stopped his benefit for three weeks until the company verified him. His account is attributed; ID.me's explanation that failures come from users is recorded.","reviewed_on":"2026-10-30"},"ai_involvement":{"basis":"Motherboard and ID.me's chief executive describe ID.me Face Match as a facial recognition step that compares a claimant's face with the photo on an identity document. The claimant says that step rejected his face three times and locked him out of the system, which cut off his unemployment benefit, and that ID.me later verified him as the same person after his public complaint. The rejection of a person the company later verified is the system's own failed match. ID.me's chief executive says such failures come from users' photos; the cause in this case is not established.","status":"reported"},"person_relations":["made_decision_about"]},"name":"Nevada unemployment claimant says ID.me face check rejected him three times and locked him out, leaving him three weeks without benefits","summary":"ID.me, an identity-verification company used by at least 21 US states to check people claiming unemployment benefits, asks claimants to pass a facial recognition step that compares their face with a photo of the same person, such as a driving licence. In June 2021 Motherboard (VICE) reported that a gig economy worker in Las Vegas was suddenly cut off from his unemployment benefits in late March after ID.me failed to identify him. He said that when he held his phone in the instructed position the system rejected him three times without giving a reason and then locked him out. He said he tried ID.me's chat support many times and the state of Nevada sent him back to ID.me; after several weeks he posted a public criticism on Twitter, and the company contacted him and, after several more days, verified his identity. He said he went three weeks without his benefit and could not pay bills. ID.me's chief executive told Motherboard that its Face Match algorithms operate at about 99.9% efficacy, that failures are a problem with how people use the system rather than the technology, and that the company was unaware of eligible people unable to verify their identity. Motherboard said other claimants in several states described similar lockouts; those accounts are not counted here.","incidentDate":"2021-03-01","incidentKind":"single_event","incidentDatePrecision":"month","exposurePattern":"repeated_interactions","reportedDate":"2021-06-18","aiSystem":"ID.me Face Match, a one-to-one facial recognition step in ID.me's identity verification for state unemployment benefit claimants, as described by Motherboard and ID.me's chief executive","aiProduct":"ID.me Face Match","aiCompany":"ID.me","severity":"low","verificationStatus":"credible","harmCategories":[],"harmOutcomes":["financial_loss","psychological_distress"],"harmOutcomeSummary":"The claimant says ID.me's face check rejected him three times and locked him out, cutting off his unemployment benefit; he says he went three weeks without it, could not pay bills, and spent weeks trying to reach ID.me and the state before the company verified him. He describes the experience as ridiculous.","frameworkFacets":[],"causationStatus":"alleged","participantUsersAffectedMin":1,"otherPeopleHarmedMin":0,"affectedCountStatus":"exact","affectedCountEvidence":"One claimant describes being rejected by the face check and losing benefits. Motherboard says other claimants in several states complained of similar problems but gives no count tied to the face check, so they are not counted.","victimAgeRange":"adult","jurisdiction":"US","platformType":"other","outcomeType":"media_coverage","outcomeStatus":"resolved","primarySourceUrl":"https://www.vice.com/en/article/facial-recognition-failures-are-locking-people-out-of-unemployment-systems/","primarySourceLabel":"Motherboard (VICE), Facial Recognition Failures Are Locking People Out of Unemployment Systems, 18 June 2021","firstPublishedAt":"2026-10-30T03:05:29.391311+00:00","updatedAt":"2026-10-30T03:05:29.391311+00:00","scopeVersion":"facts-v3","tags":["id-me","facial-recognition","unemployment-benefits","identity-verification","public-services","nevada"]},{"id":"2021-telangana-samagra-vedika-algorithm-wrongly-tagged-poor-families-as-car-owners-food-security-cards-denied","caseFacts":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'started arming the officials with Samagra Vedika, an algorithmic system that consolidates citizens'; 'the officials were mandated to check whether the algorithmic system approved the eligibility of the applicant before making their own decision'; 'They could either go with the algorithm'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"Since 2016 Telangana has used Samagra Vedika, a system that consolidates residents' data from several government databases, to check welfare eligibility; officials processing food security cards were mandated to check whether the system approved an applicant before deciding, and could depart from it only by giving reasons and evidence.","causal_attribution":"Background on the system and how its output entered officials' decisions."},{"id":"c2","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'Samagra Vedika uses'; 'to uniquely identify a person'; 'If it finds a match close enough violating any of the criteria, it tags the claimant as ineligible'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"Al Jazeera reports that Samagra Vedika uses machine learning and entity resolution technology to identify a person across databases, and tags a claimant as ineligible when it finds a close enough match violating a criterion such as owning a four-wheeler.","causal_attribution":"The description of the technology is Al Jazeera's, quoting terms whose origin the article does not state; the government describes it as using big data."},{"id":"c3","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'mistook her late husband'; 'and the authorities accepted the algorithm'; 'finally rejecting it in 2021 because they claimed she possessed a four-wheeler'; 'The authorities did not trust her'; 'they believed their algorithm'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"According to Al Jazeera, the system mistook a widow's late husband, a rickshaw puller, for a car owner with a similar name; her food security card renewal application was rejected in 2021 because she was said to possess a four-wheeler, and that the authorities believed their algorithm rather than her.","causal_attribution":"Al Jazeera attributes the rejection to the system's wrong match and officials' acceptance of it."},{"id":"c4","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'found its real owner'; 'the officials agreed there was an algorithmic error but said that her application could not be considered because her total family income exceeded the eligibility limit even though that was not the case'; 'who has been denied ration for more than seven years, is still waiting'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"After she traced the vehicle's real owner, officials agreed there had been an algorithmic error but said that her application could not be considered because family income exceeded the limit, which Al Jazeera says was not the case; she had been denied the rations for more than seven years when the article was published.","causal_attribution":"The officials' acknowledgement of an algorithmic error is reported by Al Jazeera; the continued denial rests on a different, disputed ground."},{"id":"c5","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'an algorithm has tagged the family as owning a car, denying them access to subsidised food grains'; 'The family applied for a food security card in 2018 but was rejected in 2021'; 'Instead of three rupees, we spend 10 for every kilogramme of rice'; 'the petitioner is eligible'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"A second family, whose husband cannot drive, applied in 2018 and was rejected in 2021 for possessing a four-wheeler they do not own; Al Jazeera's caption says an algorithm tagged the family as owning a car, and the woman says the family pays more for the same rice bought from dealers. In November 2023 the High Court of Telangana said the petitioner is eligible whenever the state issues new cards.","causal_attribution":"The algorithmic tag is stated in an Al Jazeera photo caption credited to The Reporters' Collective; the High Court remark is reported, not read in the order itself."},{"id":"c6","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"'The petition lists around 10 cases of wrongful exclusions'; 'Al Jazeera visited three of those and can confirm they were wrongly tagged by Samagra Vedika'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"Al Jazeera says it visited three of the roughly ten wrongful-exclusion cases listed in a Supreme Court petition and confirmed they were wrongly tagged by Samagra Vedika.","causal_attribution":"Al Jazeera's own verification; the three cases are not identified."},{"id":"c7","status":"disputed","evidence":[{"locator":"'The government has previously said that the technology is of'; 'It has also said that the error of tagging a vehicle or a house to the wrong person happens in less than five percent of all cases'; 'very high levels of accuracy'","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"The Telangana government has said the technology is of high precision, that wrong tagging of a vehicle or house occurs in less than five per cent of cases and has mostly been corrected, and an official said verifications found very high levels of accuracy.","causal_attribution":"Government counter-position; it does not address the individual cases."}],"effects":[{"label":"food security card applications rejected after the system wrongly tagged families as car owners; years without subsidised rations","claim_id":"c3","direction":"negative"}],"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2024/1/24/how-an-algorithm-denied-food-to-thousands-of-poor-in-indias-telangana","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"en","translation_note":"Read in English on 2026-10-24 (full article). Reported by Tapasya, Kumar Sambhav and Divij Joshi with The Reporters' Collective and the Pulitzer Center's AI Accountability Network; the photo captions are courtesy of The Reporters' Collective.","independence_group":"al-jazeera-reporters-collective-samagra-vedika-investigation"}],"version":1,"ai_roles":["institutional_use"],"contexts":["public_services","finance"],"unknowns":["Which three petition cases Al Jazeera verified, and how many wrongful exclusions the system itself caused.","Whether the widow's card was later issued, and whether the second family has received a card since November 2023.","How the matching works in detail; the state withheld the source code and data formats.","Why the widow's card was first cancelled in 2016."],"geography":{"basis":"Al Jazeera reports from Hyderabad that both families live there and applied to the Telangana government; the Supreme Court of India and the High Court of Telangana heard related petitions.","court_countries":["IN"],"event_countries":["IN"],"affected_person_countries":["IN"]},"publication":{"basis":"Published as a concrete adverse public decision informed by an automated matching system: Al Jazeera reports that Samagra Vedika wrongly matched a widow's late husband to a car owner and tagged another family as owning a car, and that officials rejected their food security cards on those tags; officials later acknowledged an algorithmic error in the widow's case.","reviewed_on":"2026-10-24"},"ai_involvement":{"basis":"Al Jazeera reports that Samagra Vedika matched a widow's late husband to a car owner with a similar name and tagged her family as owning a four-wheeler, that officials (mandated to check the system's approval before deciding) accepted the tag and rejected her food security card in 2021, and that they later agreed there had been an algorithmic error. It describes the system as using machine learning and entity resolution to match people across databases; the government describes it as using big data and disputes the error rate. The source code and data formats were withheld from the reporters.","status":"supported"},"person_relations":["made_claim_about","informed_decision_about"]},"name":"Al Jazeera investigation says Telangana's Samagra Vedika system wrongly matched poor families to car owners, and officials denied them food subsidy cards","summary":"An Al Jazeera investigation published on 24 January 2024, produced with The Reporters' Collective and the Pulitzer Center's AI Accountability Network, reports that Samagra Vedika, a system the Telangana government uses to consolidate residents' data and check welfare eligibility, wrongly tagged poor families in Hyderabad as owning cars, and that officials relied on those tags to deny them food security cards (subsidised rice). Al Jazeera says the system uses machine learning and entity resolution to match people across databases, and that since 2016 officials have been mandated to check whether the system approved an applicant before deciding. In one case it reports that the system mistook a widow's late husband, a rickshaw puller, for a car owner with a similar name; her renewal application was rejected in 2021 for possessing a four-wheeler. After she traced the vehicle's real owner, officials agreed there had been an algorithmic error but said her family income exceeded the limit, which Al Jazeera says was not the case; she had been without the subsidised rations for more than seven years. A second family, whose husband cannot drive, was rejected in 2021 for possessing a four-wheeler; in November 2023 the High Court of Telangana said the petitioner is eligible whenever new cards are issued. The government says the technology is highly precise and that wrong vehicle or house tags occur in under five per cent of cases and have mostly been corrected.","incidentDate":"2021-01-01","incidentKind":"bounded_series","incidentDatePrecision":"year","exposurePattern":"unknown","reportedDate":"2024-01-24","aiSystem":"Samagra Vedika, the Telangana government's data-integration and profiling system developed by Posidex Technologies, which Al Jazeera says uses machine learning and entity resolution technology to identify people across government databases and tag welfare applicants as ineligible","aiProduct":"Samagra Vedika","severity":"medium","verificationStatus":"credible","harmCategories":[],"harmOutcomes":["financial_loss","other_material_harm"],"harmOutcomeSummary":"According to an Al Jazeera investigation, Telangana's Samagra Vedika system wrongly tagged poor families as car owners and officials denied them food security cards on that basis; a widow had been without subsidised rations for over seven years and another family pays market prices for rice.","frameworkFacets":[],"causationStatus":"supported","participantUsersAffectedMin":0,"otherPeopleHarmedMin":2,"affectedCountStatus":"partial","affectedCountEvidence":"Two applicants described with their rejections: the widow and the woman whose family was rejected in 2021 (members of their households are not counted separately). Al Jazeera says it visited three of about ten petition cases and confirmed they were wrongly tagged, without listing them, and gives state re-verification figures that it does not attribute to the system alone; these are not counted.","victimAgeRange":"adult","jurisdiction":"IN","platformType":"other","outcomeType":"media_coverage","outcomeStatus":"ongoing","primarySourceUrl":"https://www.aljazeera.com/economy/2024/1/24/how-an-algorithm-denied-food-to-thousands-of-poor-in-indias-telangana","primarySourceLabel":"Al Jazeera, How an algorithm denied food to thousands of poor in India's Telangana, 24 January 2024","firstPublishedAt":"2026-10-24T03:08:52.234671+00:00","updatedAt":"2026-10-24T03:08:52.234671+00:00","scopeVersion":"facts-v3","tags":["welfare-eligibility-algorithm","entity-resolution","food-security","wrong-match","public-services"]}]}