{"meta":{"exportedAt":"2026-11-18T10:29:15.353Z","formatVersion":2,"selection":{"q":"public-services","system":"","harm":"","context":"","country":"","role":"","relation":"contextual","evidence":"","year":"2023","response":"","severity":"","verification":"","view":"incidents","sort":"added"},"totalIncidents":2,"coverage":{"cases":2,"countries":2,"languages":2,"unknownLocation":0,"locationPending":0,"unknownLanguage":0,"unknownDate":0,"lawsuits":0,"regulatory":0,"minors":0,"coreRelations":0,"contextualRelations":2,"mixedRelations":0,"unknownRelations":0,"relationPending":0,"relationUnknown":0},"countingNote":"Distinct public cases in this selection. People counts apply within individual cases only; cross-case person overlap has not been resolved. No population incidence estimate.","affectedCountNote":"Interpret person counts with affectedCountStatus and the reported effects. Unquantified zeros are placeholders, not a measured zero.","source":"AI incidents","publisher":"NOPE","url":"https://nope.net/incidents","license":"CC BY 4.0"},"incidents":[{"id":"2023-netherlands-driver-says-police-ai-phone-camera-flagged-him-for-holding-phone-while-scratching-head-380-euro-fine","caseFacts":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"De slimme camera’s van de politie zijn uitgerust met kunstmatige intelligentie.; De foto van de overtreding moet ook nog door een agent worden gecontroleerd.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"},{"locator":"Dat is een mobiele flitscamera van de politie die met kunstmatige intelligentie registreert of iemand aan het bellen is.; Bij flitsfoto's gemaakt met een MONOcam moet een agent altijd nog zelf de foto beoordelen op overtredingen.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"},{"locator":"In de video wordt uitgelegd dat een algoritme bepaalt of iemand een mobiel apparaat vasthoudt tijdens het rijden. Vervolgens moet een politiemedewerker beoordelen of er daadwerkelijk een overtreding is begaan.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"Dutch police use mobile smart cameras with artificial intelligence that judge from a photo whether a driver is holding a mobile phone, after which a police officer reviews the photo before a fine is issued.","causal_attribution":"Description of the system by two outlets and by the driver from a police video; no police statement on this case."},{"id":"c2","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Volgens de officiële beschikking had ik halverwege oktober als bestuurder tijdens het rijden een mobiel elektrisch apparaat vastgehouden.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"kreeg meteen een boete van 380 euro. Plus nog 9 euro administratiekosten.; vroeg hij de foto van de overtreding op de snelweg A2 bij Weert op.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"},{"locator":"Maar de politie oordeelde dat hij zat te bellen. Kosten: 380 euro en 9 euro voor de administratie.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"}],"assertion":"The driver received a fine of 380 euros plus 9 euros in administration costs for holding a mobile device while driving, for a photo taken on the A2 motorway near Weert in October 2023.","causal_attribution":"The driver's account of the fine notice, repeated by both outlets from interviews with him; the notice itself was not inspected."},{"id":"c3","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Op de foto is te zien dat ik mijn hand bij mijn gezicht heb, maar ik heb niks vast in mijn hand.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"Ik heb een auto met de mogelijkheid om er handsfree te bellen. Ook ben ik linkshandig, maar ik krab daar met mijn rechterhand aan mijn hoofd.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"},{"locator":"Op de flitsfoto was te zien dat hij tijdens het rijden over de A2 bij Weert aan zijn hoofd zat.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"}],"assertion":"The driver says the flash photo shows his empty hand near his face because he was scratching his head, that his car allows hands-free calling and that he is left-handed.","causal_attribution":"The driver's own account of the photo; RTL describes the photo it published."},{"id":"c4","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"wordt uitgelegd hoe de Monocam, de camera die mij geflitst heeft, gebruikt wordt.; In mijn geval heeft het algoritme dus gezegd dat ik een mobiel apparaat vasthoud tijdens het rijden én de medewerker van de politie heeft dat geaccepteerd.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"is waarschijnlijk gemaakt door een MONOcam.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"},{"locator":"Deze AI-camera had zich dus vergist.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"The driver says the camera was a MONOcam whose algorithm judged that he was holding a mobile device and that the reviewing police employee accepted that judgement; RTL Nieuws reported that the photo was probably taken by a MONOcam, and Omroep Brabant described the fine as the AI camera's mistake.","causal_attribution":"The driver's inference from a police video and the photo; RTL hedges the camera model; no police confirmation."},{"id":"c5","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Die agent was waarschijnlijk bevooroordeeld, omdat het algoritme zei dat ik aan het bellen was.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"},{"locator":"Als je heel snel naar de foto kijkt, kun je denken: ‘Die zal wel zitten te bellen’. Er is een donkere schaduw in mijn hand te zien.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"The driver said the reviewing officer was probably biased because the algorithm said he was phoning, and that on a quick look a dark shadow in his hand could suggest a phone.","causal_attribution":"The driver's own interpretation."},{"id":"c6","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Uiteraard ben ik in bezwaar gegaan, maar daar heb ik nog geen uitslag van.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"Ik heb bezwaar gemaakt. Ik ben in afwachting daarvan.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"},{"locator":"heeft bezwaar tegen de boete aangetekend, maar dat is nog niet in behandeling genomen door het Openbaar Ministerie (OM).; Het CJIB laat weten dat zij over individuele gevallen geen uitspraken kunnen doen,; laat doorschemeren dat de kans klein is dat de man de boete ook echt moet betalen.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s3"}],"assertion":"The driver lodged an objection, which had not yet been handled by the Public Prosecution Service when the reports appeared in February 2024; a CJIB spokesperson declined to comment on individual cases but suggested the chance he would really have to pay was small.","causal_attribution":"The driver's statements and RTL's report of the CJIB spokesperson."},{"id":"c7","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"De camera’s zijn super waardevol.; Je moet alleen twijfelgevallen niet bekeuren.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"The driver told Omroep Brabant that he still considers the smart cameras very valuable, provided that doubtful cases are not fined.","causal_attribution":"The driver's own qualification, kept as context."}],"effects":[{"label":"driver fined 380 euros plus costs after an AI phone-detection flag on a photo showing his empty hand","claim_id":"c2","direction":"negative"}],"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://nippur.nl/tim-versus-politie-algoritme/","kind":"first_person_account","access":"read","language":"nl","translation_note":"Read in Dutch on 2026-11-01; passages translated into English by the research agent (an AI). Read from an Internet Archive capture of 2 May 2025 because the site did not respond.","independence_group":"driver-blog-2024-02"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.omroepbrabant.nl/nieuws/4423832/tim-geflitst-door-slimme-camera-380-euro-voor-krabben-aan-oor","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"nl","translation_note":"Read in Dutch on 2026-11-01; passages translated into English by the research agent (an AI). The article interviews the driver.","independence_group":"omroep-brabant-2024-02-20"},{"id":"s3","url":"https://www.rtl.nl/nieuws/sport/artikel/5436204/tim-krijgt-boete-van-380-euro-voor-krabben-aan-zijn-hoofd","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"nl","translation_note":"Read in Dutch on 2026-11-01; passages translated into English by the research agent (an AI). Read from an Internet Archive capture of 17 April 2025 because the site returned HTTP 403; the article interviews the driver and quotes CJIB and OM spokespeople.","independence_group":"rtl-nieuws-2024-02-21"}],"version":1,"ai_roles":["institutional_use"],"contexts":["public_services","justice"],"unknowns":["Whether the objection succeeded or the fine was paid; no decision has been reported since February 2024.","Whether the camera was in fact a MONOcam; the police have not confirmed the device, and RTL says only that it was probably one.","The exact date of the photo: the driver's blog says mid-October 2023 and RTL says the end of October."],"geography":{"basis":"The photo was taken on the A2 motorway near Weert in the Netherlands, according to the driver and both outlets; RTL Nieuws describes him as a man from a Dutch town, and the fine was issued through the Dutch CJIB.","court_countries":[],"event_countries":["NL"],"affected_person_countries":["NL"]},"publication":{"basis":"Published as a police AI phone-detection camera flagging a driver whose photo, by his account, shows an empty hand at his head, with an officer approving the flag and a 380-euro fine issued. The driver's account, the hedged camera identification and the unresolved objection are attributed.","reviewed_on":"2026-11-01"},"ai_involvement":{"basis":"Omroep Brabant and RTL Nieuws describe the police camera as using artificial intelligence to register whether a driver is holding a phone, and the driver writes that its algorithm judged that he was holding a mobile device while the photo shows his empty hand at his head; an officer then accepted that flag and the fine followed, so the system's recognition output is reported as wrong and as informing the officer's decision. The camera model rests on the driver's account and RTL's 'probably'; the police have not commented on the case.","status":"reported"},"person_relations":["made_claim_about","informed_decision_about"]},"name":"Dutch driver says police AI phone camera flagged him for holding a phone while he scratched his head, and an officer approved a 380-euro fine","summary":"Dutch police use mobile smart cameras that apply artificial intelligence to photos of passing drivers to detect whether they are holding a mobile phone; a police officer then reviews each flagged photo before a fine is issued. A driver says that in October 2023, on the A2 motorway near Weert, such a camera photographed him with his right hand at his head and that he received a fine of 380 euros plus 9 euros in administration costs for holding a mobile device while driving. He says the flash photo, which he requested from the Central Judicial Collection Agency (CJIB), shows his empty hand near his face: he was scratching his head, his lease car allows hands-free calling, and he is left-handed. In a February 2024 blog post he writes that the camera was a MONOcam, that its algorithm judged that he was holding a device and that the reviewing police employee accepted that judgement, so that both the algorithm and a person erred; RTL Nieuws reported that the photo was probably taken by a MONOcam. Omroep Brabant described the fine as a mistake by the AI camera. The driver said the reviewing officer was probably biased by the algorithm's output and that a dark shadow in his hand could mislead a quick look. He lodged an objection with the Public Prosecution Service; it had not been decided when the reports appeared in February 2024, and a CJIB spokesperson, who would not comment on individual cases, suggested to RTL that he was unlikely to have to pay. No later outcome has been reported. He also told Omroep Brabant that he considers the cameras valuable for road safety, provided doubtful cases are not fined.","incidentDate":"2023-10-01","incidentKind":"single_event","incidentDatePrecision":"month","exposurePattern":"single_interaction","reportedDate":"2024-02-20","aiSystem":"Dutch police mobile smart traffic camera that uses artificial intelligence to flag drivers apparently holding a mobile phone, with each flag reviewed by a police officer; identified as a MONOcam by the driver's blog and as probably a MONOcam by RTL Nieuws","aiProduct":"MONOcam (reported)","severity":"low","verificationStatus":"credible","harmCategories":[],"harmOutcomes":["financial_loss"],"harmOutcomeSummary":"The driver says he was fined 380 euros plus 9 euros in costs for holding a phone while driving after a police AI camera flagged him and an officer approved the flag, although the photo shows his empty hand at his head; he lodged an objection, whose outcome has not been reported.","frameworkFacets":[],"causationStatus":"alleged","participantUsersAffectedMin":0,"otherPeopleHarmedMin":1,"affectedCountStatus":"exact","affectedCountEvidence":"One driver, who describes his own fine in his blog post and in interviews with Omroep Brabant and RTL Nieuws.","victimAgeRange":"adult","jurisdiction":"NL","platformType":"other","outcomeType":"media_coverage","outcomeStatus":"unknown","primarySourceUrl":"https://www.omroepbrabant.nl/nieuws/4423832/tim-geflitst-door-slimme-camera-380-euro-voor-krabben-aan-oor","primarySourceLabel":"Omroep Brabant, Tim geflitst door slimme camera: 380 euro voor krabben aan oor, 20 February 2024","firstPublishedAt":"2026-11-01T03:07:21.222094+00:00","updatedAt":"2026-11-01T03:07:21.222094+00:00","scopeVersion":"facts-v3","tags":["traffic-camera","phone-detection","traffic-fine","police","netherlands","public-services"]},{"id":"2023-us-mexico-border-cbp-one-asylum-app-face-capture-failed-black-applicants-advocates-say","caseFacts":{"claims":[{"id":"c1","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"The government announced in early January that the new CBP One mobile app would be the only way migrants arriving at the border can apply for asylum and exemption from Title 42 restrictions; which is now required to apply for asylum","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"the Biden administration announced in early January that the CBP One app would be the only way people at the border can apply for asylum and an exemption from Title 42.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"In early January 2023 the US government announced that the CBP One app would be the only way migrants arriving at the US-Mexico border could apply for asylum and exemption from Title 42 restrictions; uploading a photo through the app was required to obtain an appointment.","causal_attribution":"Government announcement as reported; the photo requirement is the reporter's and advocates' description."},{"id":"c2","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Non-profits that assist Black asylum seekers are finding that the app, CBP One, is failing to register many people with darker skin tones, effectively barring them from their right to request entry into the US.; The facial recognition is not picking up [images] if people have darker skin tones,; held a workshop for Haitians in Tijuana on how to use the app a day after it went live on 12 January. But with the app unable to map the features of many darker-skinned asylum seekers, they cannot upload their photos in order to receive an asylum appointment with the US immigration authorities, Pinheiro said.; The Haitians at the workshop were getting error after error message on the app","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"Because the app cannot map the features of darker-skinned asylum seekers, they cannot upload their photo to receive an asylum appointment, Pinheiro said.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"Non-profits assisting Black asylum seekers said the app's facial recognition was failing to register many people with darker skin tones, so they could not upload their photos to receive asylum appointments; Al Otro Lado's executive director said Haitians at a Tijuana workshop held the day after the app went live on 12 January got error after error message.","causal_attribution":"Advocates' accounts of what they observed; no technical analysis or CBP confirmation is reported."},{"id":"c3","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"There are about 4,000 Black asylum seekers waiting in Reynosa and at least another 1,000 Haitians in Matamoros. Hardly anyone is getting an asylum appointment.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"The co-director of the Sidewalk School said about 4,000 Black asylum seekers were waiting in Reynosa and at least 1,000 Haitians in Matamoros, and that hardly anyone was getting an asylum appointment.","causal_attribution":"The non-profit's estimate; the figures describe people waiting and are not counted as people harmed."},{"id":"c4","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"One fix they’ve come up with is installing bright construction lights at the shelter in Reynosa, which Haitians and others shine on their faces as they take the photo to upload to the app. “So far it seems to be working, so the adults can get past that,; still not working for children under the age of six.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"This prevents families from being able to apply for asylum, since the app will accept only one or two members of the family, but not the rest.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"The Sidewalk School said shining bright construction lights on faces let adults get past the photo step, but it still did not work for children under six, which prevented families from applying because the app accepted only some family members.","causal_attribution":"The non-profit's account of its workaround and of families blocked."},{"id":"c5","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"said the CBP One app has helped “lighter-skin toned people from other nations” obtain their asylum appointments “but not Haitians” and other Black applicants.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"A Haitian Bridge Alliance staff attorney said the app had helped lighter-skinned people from other nations obtain asylum appointments, but not Haitians and other Black applicants.","causal_attribution":"Advocate's comparison; not measured."},{"id":"c6","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"Besides the face recognition technology not registering them, there are other barriers, too. Many asylum seekers have outdated cellphones – if they have cellphones at all – that don’t support the CBP One app and often have limited or no access to the internet.; If you can afford to spend $1,000 on a new cellphone, then you can upload the image no problem.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"}],"assertion":"The advocates also described barriers unrelated to facial recognition: many asylum seekers had outdated phones that did not support the app, or limited internet access, and a new phone could upload the image.","causal_attribution":"Kept as context: other causes of failed uploads that the sources do not separate from the face capture."},{"id":"c7","status":"reported","evidence":[{"locator":"CBP did not reply with comments before publication, after being approached with questions by the Guardian.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s1"},{"locator":"The Border Chronicle contacted CBP with several detailed questions about the CBP One app, including the problems with its facial-recognition technology. A spokesperson for CBP, Justin Long, said no one was available to respond.","relation":"supports","source_id":"s2"}],"assertion":"CBP did not reply to the Guardian's questions before publication, and a CBP spokesperson told the Border Chronicle no one was available to respond.","causal_attribution":"The agency's non-response."}],"effects":[{"label":"advocates say darker-skinned asylum seekers could not pass the app's photo step to obtain appointments","claim_id":"c2","direction":"negative"},{"label":"advocates say families with children under six could not apply","claim_id":"c4","direction":"negative"}],"sources":[{"id":"s1","url":"https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/08/us-immigration-cbp-one-app-facial-recognition-bias","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"en","translation_note":"Read in English on 2026-10-31; no translation.","independence_group":"del-bosque-cbp-one-2023-02"},{"id":"s2","url":"https://www.theborderchronicle.com/p/facing-bias-cbps-immigration-app","kind":"news_report","access":"read","language":"en","translation_note":"Read in English on 2026-10-31 from an Internet Archive capture of 26 February 2024; no translation. Same reporter as the Guardian article.","independence_group":"del-bosque-cbp-one-2023-02"}],"version":1,"ai_roles":["institutional_use"],"contexts":["public_services","justice"],"unknowns":["How many people the app's face capture rejected; the advocates give no count.","Whether the rejections came from the facial recognition itself, phone cameras or lighting; no technical analysis is reported.","Whether CBP changed the face capture or how long the problem lasted; neither source reports a later response."],"geography":{"basis":"The advocates describe asylum seekers using the app while waiting in the Mexican border cities of Tijuana, Reynosa and Matamoros to request entry into the United States.","court_countries":[],"event_countries":["MX"],"affected_person_countries":["MX"]},"publication":{"basis":"Published as a government asylum app whose facial recognition, according to non-profits that assisted applicants, rejected the photos of many Black asylum seekers so they could not obtain appointments, the only route then available. The account is attributed to the advocates; other barriers and CBP's non-response are recorded.","reviewed_on":"2026-10-31"},"ai_involvement":{"basis":"Non-profits running workshops and shelters for asylum seekers told the Guardian and the Border Chronicle that the CBP One app's facial recognition did not register the faces of many darker-skinned applicants: the app returned error messages and would not accept their photos, which were required to obtain an asylum appointment through the app, the only route CBP allowed at the time. The rejection of the photo is the system's own output and the advocates connect it to applicants being unable to get appointments. The attribution rests on the advocates' observations; no technical analysis is reported, CBP did not respond, and the advocates also cite old phones and poor connectivity.","status":"reported"},"person_relations":["made_decision_about"]},"name":"Advocates say CBP One asylum app's facial recognition rejected photos of Black asylum seekers at the US-Mexico border, blocking appointments","summary":"In January 2023 US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) made its CBP One mobile app the only way for migrants at the US-Mexico border to apply for asylum appointments and exemption from Title 42 restrictions; applicants had to upload a photo of themselves through the app. In February 2023 the Guardian and the Border Chronicle, both reporting by Melissa del Bosque, quoted three non-profits working with Haitian and African asylum seekers in Tijuana, Reynosa and Matamoros who said the app's facial recognition was failing to register many people with darker skin, so they could not upload their photos and obtain appointments. The executive director of Al Otro Lado said Haitians at a workshop her organisation held in Tijuana the day after the app went live got error after error message. The Sidewalk School said hardly anyone among about 4,000 Black asylum seekers in Reynosa and 1,000 Haitians in Matamoros was getting an appointment, and that shining construction lights on faces let adults get past the photo step but not children under six, which kept families from applying. A Haitian Bridge Alliance attorney said the app had helped lighter-skinned applicants but not Haitians. The advocates also described other barriers, such as outdated phones and poor internet access. CBP did not answer the Guardian's questions before publication and told the Border Chronicle no one was available to respond. No technical analysis of the failures is reported.","incidentDate":"2023-01-01","incidentKind":"bounded_series","incidentDatePrecision":"month","exposurePattern":"repeated_interactions","reportedDate":"2023-02-07","aiSystem":"Facial recognition photo capture in US Customs and Border Protection's CBP One mobile app, required in 2023 for migrants at the US-Mexico border to request asylum appointments, as described by non-profits quoted by the Guardian and the Border Chronicle","aiProduct":"CBP One app","severity":"low","verificationStatus":"credible","harmCategories":[],"harmOutcomes":["legal_harm","other_material_harm"],"harmOutcomeSummary":"Advocates say the app's facial recognition failed to register many darker-skinned asylum seekers, so they could not upload their photos or obtain the asylum appointments the app had become the only route to; they say lighting workarounds helped adults but not children under six, which kept families from applying.","frameworkFacets":[],"causationStatus":"alleged","participantUsersAffectedMin":0,"otherPeopleHarmedMin":0,"affectedCountStatus":"unquantified","affectedCountEvidence":"The advocates describe groups (Haitians at a Tijuana workshop, families with young children at a Reynosa shelter) without counts. The figures of about 4,000 Black asylum seekers in Reynosa and 1,000 Haitians in Matamoros describe people waiting, not people whose photos the app rejected, so they are not counted.","victimAgeRange":"unknown","jurisdiction":"US","platformType":"other","outcomeType":"media_coverage","outcomeStatus":"unknown","primarySourceUrl":"https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/08/us-immigration-cbp-one-app-facial-recognition-bias","primarySourceLabel":"The Guardian, Facial recognition bias frustrates Black asylum applicants to US, advocates say, 8 February 2023","firstPublishedAt":"2026-10-31T03:21:06.698324+00:00","updatedAt":"2026-10-31T03:21:06.698324+00:00","scopeVersion":"facts-v3","tags":["cbp-one","facial-recognition","asylum","immigration","public-services","us-mexico-border"]}]}